Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Movie Buzz 
 The Renovators - smash or trash? Have your say 

The Renovators - smash or trash? Have your say

I was having enough trouble keeping track of the nobodies on MasterChef Australia and The Block. Then along comes Jamie Dreary’s Top Design (NBN, 8.30pm Wednesday) and The Renovators (Southern Cross Ten, six nights a week).

Now prime-time is wall-to-gyprocked-wall with no-name wannabes.

No wonder so many actors are taking your order at cafes when ordinary folk are taking all the starring roles on television.

A decade ago, as the reality TV competition formats took off with Survivor, Gary Shandling, star of the brilliant late-night talk show satire The Larry Sanders Show, won applause from an audience of actors at the Emmys when he remarked that ‘‘real people shouldn’t be on television’’.

“It’s for special people like us who have trained and studied to appear to be real,” Shandling said.

The problem now is that even “real” people on shows like MasterChef appear to have trained and studied to appear to be real. It’s one of the reasons people tell me they’ve gone off MasterChef: silly challenges, fake contestants and dodgy verdicts.

MasterChef? Preposterous, prepackaged and ultimately pointless?

Hello? It’s hosted by a bloke in a cravat, people!

I can’t verify if MasterChef has gone off the boil. I haven’t watched an episode this year. Life’s too short.

I’d rather watch Angry Boys and feel angry that it’s not funny than watch MasterChef and feel empty.

So, now we have The Renovators, aka MasterChef with hammers.

Of course, with The Block sponsored by one hardware chain and The Renovators backed by another, their ultimate purpose – like supermarket-sponsored MasterChef – is as screamingly obvious as that ad for flat-pack kitchens during Sunday’s Renovators opener.

The question is can The Renovators top the absurdity of MasterChef, which had the audacity to take its amateur cooks to the UN in New York and recruit the Dalai Lama as a guest.

I’m thinking a retiled bathroom in the International Space Station and a Mystery Toolbox Challenge with the Pope.

And another thing ...

I know an otherwise sensible bloke who records every MasterChef to watch when he gets home from work late at night, usually over a reheated dinner.

This can’t be healthy. Studies show that such fatty, sugary, high-carb cooking shows consumed immediately before bed can lead to indigestion, heartburn and a dangerously increased partiality to cravats.

So, now, over to you. Are you over reality TV yet? Or do you lap up these shows like an underfed MasterChef judge?

Do you prefer The Block or The Renovators? What do you make of Top Design? Any good?

And MasterChef Australia - has it lost the plot completely this year?

Share your thoughts here.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Trash, never have i seen a bunch of stuck up misfits like that lot.
Posted by dally-girl, 29/07/2011 10:16:55 PM, on The Herald
Anything with just a hint of some form of 'elimination' in it is enough for me to switch off. The problem is it is now getting difficult to find anything (well, on commercial tv anyway) that isn't reality based. Sooooo over reality! Needless to say I am not watching much TV these days...........and loving it.
Posted by geeman, 29/07/2011 11:46:50 PM, on The Herald
haha actors are taking orders because australian drama shows are absolute rubbish and keep using the same actors from underbelly and home and away. You would have to be a goose to want to become an actor. Yet they all seem to think they are better and more original than the next actor. Yet they all seem to live in a dream land saying they are actors on their tax return, when most of their income comes from working in the hospitality industry haha. Lucky I have Foxtel. FTA Tv seems very outdated and ordinary after you experience the vast array of quality shows on foxtel
Posted by benaud, 30/07/2011 6:19:51 AM, on The Herald
screaming at me every 5 minutes how crazy harvey normans prices are. Australian tv shows keep trying to re-invent the same old format. How can you try and like a character in a show when you just keep relating them to the underbelly series. No room for character development when you are getting ready for someone in that stupid police rescue show to try and sell someone stuck in a car hanging over a cliff a pill or get ready to shoot him haha. RIP Australian Actors and TV
Posted by benaud, 30/07/2011 6:21:31 AM, on The Herald
Trash - enough said. I'm sick of most reality shows, they bore me.
Posted by Dave, 30/07/2011 7:47:40 AM, on The Herald
As a Tradesmen, I cannot believe some of the Shonky work that is done on some of these Shows.... I have never had an Issue in over 30 years, as I Like to do it Properly or don't do it at all....I would steer someone right away from any Property that was offered for sale at a later date....I believe Its a real Worry for some poor unsuspecting buyer.
Posted by Concerned, 30/07/2011 10:44:54 AM, on The Herald
I have never been into reality shows ever since the early ones like the great race.

To me it these shows just demonstrate how much contempt the TV stations have for their supposed viewers and their sponsors ie advertisers.

Posted by Richard from Tasmania, 30/07/2011 2:17:31 PM, on The Herald
Probably not much to do with the request for an opinion about renovators, but since Masterchef came into the discussion ... I admit to dedication to that series but wonder whether I missed something. In all the talk about presentation, taste, texture, etc., etc., Has anyone ever mentioned a connection between satisfying hunger and food? I'd be outraged to be presented with, and expected to pay for, some of those "presentations."

E.

Posted by Elaine, 30/07/2011 3:58:26 PM, on The Herald
I find it is not the contestants on these shows that are the problem. After all the producers make most of the decisions. In essence the shows are about food and building/renovation. It is the judges and editing that bore me. Stuck up judges, some who have difficulty with pronunciation ( it's Elements George not Allements and her name is Ellie not Allie). As for the Block: the games and the poor filming of the rooms have stopped that being anything about renovation. Sorry but in a show that runs for 6 hrs a week we see the final product for 30 seconds! Boring. The Renovators is somewhat refreshing. At least so far the we see a finished product each show and the judges seem positive and deliver constructive criticism . That can hardly be said for the snippy judge who doesn't like orange on top design. The stuck up attitude on TD will see it fail.

Submitted via iPhone App

Posted by Andy, 31/07/2011 4:16:56 PM
trash
Posted by zinc53, 1/08/2011 3:21:27 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2  |  next >
Movie Buzz
The Newcastle Herald's resident movie critic and TV columnist James Joyce casts his critical eye over the big and little screens.
The Renovators host Brendan Moar
The Renovators host Brendan Moar
Related Coverage
BLOGS
23 July, 2011

Most popular articles




Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...