Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 An inspired compromise? 

An inspired compromise?

Every day readers tell me about their encounter with a hostile establishment, disinterested business or scammers, and often, too, they'll relay what is simply an observation. While these are always interesting not all can provide the structure for a column, but in The Herald today I tell of three such calls I received in succession.

One is about Apia (formerly Australian Pensioners Insurance) increasing its premium for landlord insurance for a house from $562 to $1426 when it learnt that the house was in Maryland NSW, not Maryland Tasmania! And another caller despairs that he must wait at least seven weeks for a simple plastic part for his three-year-old Whirlpool washing machine.

But today I'm especially interested in your response to a third caller who told of an incident at a prisoners' family barbecue at Cessnock Correctional Centre on Sunday. One family was cooking pork sausages, which they'd bought at the jail, on the provided long barbecue when a family identifying themselves as Muslims - they appeared to be of Lebanese background - protested that pork was being cooked on the plate they'd be using. The first family was not receptive to this concern and continued cooking lunch, whereupon the second family protested to the supervising prison officers. The prison officers then told those cooking the pork sausages that they could continue to do so only if they put tinfoil on the plate.

Was that an inspired compromise? Should there be such compromise?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
communal barbecue facilities? imagine a vegetarian telling you they want to cook some spuds on the plate later so don't cook any meat on it now.... no chance. if you have specialised barbecue requirements then you are the one that has to compromise, not the generic barbecuer (is that a word?). anyhow, how much pork has already gone across that plate over the years? and if they had already started to cook then it's too late anyway. sounds like some religious nutters going to extremes to be a pain in the backside to me. situation normal.
Posted by judgedredd, 23/06/2010 2:36:03 PM, on The Herald
far be it for me to defend insurance companies (thieving bottom feeders that they are), but they do base their premiums on algorithms worked from claims experience. So if you live in an area where more claims are made and paid, your premiums will be higher. They also use exemptions to elements of anti-discrimination laws because they can base their discrimination on statistical evidence. eg. they can charge a 23yr old male driver a higher premium than a 23 yr female with identical driving history and geographic location, because they can prove statistically that the male is a higher risk. It is clear sex discrimination, but allowed under the law because they can demonstrate the increased risk/cost to provide the cover to the male. the details in this example are made up only to demonstrate the principle. Same elements in play here - clearly the claims history in Tassie is better than it is up here in the real world.
Posted by fista, 23/06/2010 2:44:26 PM, on The Herald
It's a bloody prison! What are they doing having barbecues?
Posted by moron, 23/06/2010 2:55:41 PM, on The Herald
The Wise, The Magnificient, The Great Mufti of Australia, Sheik Hilaly, has the answer: "If you take out uncovered meat and place it outside on the street, or in the garden or in the park, or in the backyard without a cover, and the cats come and eat it ... whose fault is it, the cats' or the uncovered meat? The uncovered meat is the problem. If she was in her room, in her home, in her hijab, no problem would have occurred." Which by interpretation means: You are all jailbirds - Fair suck of the pork saveloy!
Posted by Thicke Sheik, 23/06/2010 3:16:56 PM, on The Herald
Whats all the fuss about a "pork sausage" A scenario: In a family group, 6 members will eat anything that moves or is stationary; including "bulls testicles" at a restaurant. Another two are strict muslim. One is a "strict vegan"; will not eat, or wear, any animal product. Compromise, easy, "thats my family".
Posted by old boy, 23/06/2010 3:21:11 PM, on The Herald
The second lot should have had a hunger strike.
Posted by Lateral Thinking, 23/06/2010 3:27:40 PM, on The Herald
Compromise is also being respectful about other peoples views - so this is an inspired compromise on the prison officer's behalf...no harm done...and they still have to eat inside...it's not all "salt pork and molasses" as Tina Turner would have us believe.
Posted by stevo106, 23/06/2010 3:31:36 PM, on The Herald
Unfortunately this is an issue that can't really be compromised. The muslims will now not eat anything off that hotplate, and the non-muslims don't see why they should have to change their cooking methods honed over many generations to placate a minority group who don't make concessions to anyone else whose beliefs or lifestyle doesn't fit their narrow views. The irony is that the muslims have probably eaten off this hotplate for years - just because a sausage isn't called "a pork sausage" doesn't mean it doesn't contain piggy products! It's just the majority of the "meat" is from other animals. Why should the non-muslims (the majority in this country) be forced into having boring BBQ's without being able to brown their chops/sausages nicely on the hotplate? I suggest the only way to deal with this is to give the muslims their own little BBQ so they can keep themselves pure. Mind you, do they still wash themselves (including private parts) in the handbasins where others have to wash their face & hands? My husband had to put up with that at his place of work.
Posted by butterfly, 23/06/2010 5:42:43 PM, on The Herald
Ime going to put my white anglo uneducated hand up here and ask, is this Kosher?
Posted by horse, 23/06/2010 6:41:00 PM, on The Herald
old boy..sounds like an interesting family .as for the sausage issue , even beef sausages are in pig intestine casing.
Posted by catl, 23/06/2010 6:49:55 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...