Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Asian drivers 

Asian drivers

It is, I think, as entrenched a stereotype as that relating to women drivers: Asian drivers are poor drivers, to be given a wide berth, drivers we don't want in front of us, behind us or next to us. And my bells ring more loudly when I'm on my bike.

But what's this! Sydney University researchers claim that young Australians born in Asia are significantly safer than Australian drivers born everywhere else. Their crash risk is half that of Australia-born drivers. The researchers used answers from 21,000 P-platers aged to 25 and crash reports provided by police to arrive at a startling result few people would be prepared to believe!

I mean, not only have we seen the madness that passes as traffic in Asia's capital cities, we've had experiences with Asian drivers in Australia. The driving of men wearing hats, lady bowlers in their whites and women in general is seriously competent by comparison.

So how could there be such a gap between the stereotype and the research result? Well, it's this that especially interests me, and a credible answer has been provided by a Sydney clinical psychologist, Jeroen Decates. In a Sydney newspaper's report of the research into the driving of different ethnic groups, Mr Decates explains why a stereotype can be self-perpetuating. We are more likely, he says, to note that a poor driver is of an Asian background if this is evidence for the stereotype we hold. We are always, he says, looking for confirmation of our beliefs. I suppose, too, that drivers of Asian stock are more readily identifed and grouped than, say, drivers of British stock. It may be meaningless to stereotype Caucasian people as bad drivers, and if that is the case it should be as meaningless, I suppose, to do the same for Asian people.

But all the psychology, all the stats, all the research adds up to nought when we're stuck behind an Asia driver. Perhaps, like women drivers, it's the chaos they leave in their wake that is the problem.

What are your driving stereotypes? Do you accept that you may be perpetuating these unfairly?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
P Platers and old people in gold or silver cars.
Posted by Gen X, 21/06/2010 10:38:32 AM, on The Herald
statistics...... bah!! this story reminds me of Capt. Parmenter in F-Troop. Nothing seems to happen to him but all around him are disasters which he is oblivious to. its kind of hard to become a stereotype without some good reason..... lol @ old drivers. women drivers, cowboy truck drivers, p-plate drivers, drivers wearing hats, asian drivers, real aussies in their bundy rum utes and middle eastern hoons in their turbo japanese rocket powered doof doof mobiles.
Posted by judgedredd, 21/06/2010 10:39:20 AM, on The Herald
How do you know that they are Australians if they were born in Asia? Did they study only concentrate on those who have taken out Australian citizenship?
Posted by moron, 21/06/2010 10:57:51 AM, on The Herald
The same occurred to me fleetingly, moron, but I don't think it makes a difference.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 21/06/2010 11:05:06 AM
I am of similar opinion on women drivers Jeff especially the younger variety in there beep beep buzz boxes ripping around at warp 7.I am going to give my mother a wrap though if i may.Whilst recently travelling from her house in the outskirts of Lae ,Morobi province PNG,she had a rock thrown through her drivers side window smashing the glass and just grazing her head,with the rock about the size of your fist ending up on the rear window ledge.All the while she kept control of the car.Unlike the bus driver who also copped the same through his front window and ended up putting it in the gully injuring several passengers. I,m happy to report justice was metered out after one of the passengers of the bus recognised the rock thrower, formed a possey and burnt his house down.
Posted by horse, 21/06/2010 11:01:35 AM, on The Herald
Excellent!
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 21/06/2010 11:04:05 AM
Asian drivers Jeff...my experience of them is this...these guys are geniuses, they have eyes in the back of their heads, they drive by sense of feel, they must use a form of Chi magic, I am sure of it, as no one with just simple, ordinary, driving skills could steer a car through gaps that do not seem to be there, will miss errant pedestrians by millimetres, will miss having collisions with the million and a half bicycles and electric scooters on a minute to minute basis and all this is done with a pathological oversight of red lights, green lights, white lights, etc. I will also add that this is done without a scowl, an angry word or an angry gesture, there is zero roadrage...yes! zero...the drivers here are geniuses. Australia needs more of them.
Posted by suzhousid, 21/06/2010 12:38:28 PM, on The Herald
Beautifully put, sid. But here, I'm afraid, this skill you describe seems to become hesitancy and confusion. It is a puzzle.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 21/06/2010 12:48:17 PM
Jeff I will also add this...try sitting in a cab while all of this is going on...it is like..."arrrrrgh! shit!..jesus ' h' christ ,..man ! are you right in the head!" (my usual reaction)..and he or she will slowly turn their head and with an inscrutiable, wise and sagely Eastern look will placedly nod and continue. It is frighteningly funny.
Posted by suzhousid, 21/06/2010 1:03:25 PM, on The Herald
I imagine the road rule outlawing cyclists riding two abreast on bends in areas with a >60 kmh speed limit must be the cause of numerous accidents, irrespective of the ethnicity of the driver, due to the RTA omitting it from any of their publications. The confusion it causes is dreadful. Should a motorist give way to these law breakers, or just mow them down?
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 21/06/2010 1:11:12 PM, on The Herald
My personal opinion is that drivers education should be compulsory within school curriculum in the senior years of schooling.
Posted by The Real Tough Titties, 21/06/2010 2:36:51 PM, on The Herald
never mind the asian drivers, anyone with an exhaust pipe greater than 50mm diameter should be struck many times with a piece of pipe the same size. and what about the tossers who drive around with fog lights on all day and night...which is illegal and blinding...looks really cool though.., just like a car bra.
Posted by catl, 21/06/2010 2:53:32 PM, on The Herald
I must disagree. The only thing that will help is if the RTA make full and frank admissions about their terrible oversight with their road rules. How could they have possibly left out such an important rule. It's lucky that cyclists have the Fernleigh track to ride upon. Apparently the two ladies whose brainchild it was originally intended it to be for walkers only, at least that is what I have read in the past. I think it might have been in the Star. Anyway, now they can be safely off the road, and away from any bends.
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 21/06/2010 3:00:13 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...