Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Camouflaged cars 

Camouflaged cars

The capacity for a car to be lost in its background depends, of course, on the colour of the car and the colour of the background. I've long argued that the most common background is the road itself, a bitumen surface that ranges in colour from silver to charcoal, and this camouflage effect is most dangerous when the car is approaching the looker. A typical instance of that occurs when the looker is waiting at a T intersection and the car is approaching on his right. This circumstance, I believe, puts cars that are silver, grey, charcoal and dark blue at greater risk of being involved in an accident, but despite many requests over a decade I've not been able to get the necessary help for such a study.

As I report in my column today, NRMA Insurance has just released the results of an examination of its own records to show that dark cars, and it mentions black, green and blue, are involved in 10 per cent more accidents that cars of lighter colours. As well, it found that the average cost of accident repairs for dark cars was higher than that for other cars, suggesting that these dark cars are involved in more serious accidents.

NRMA Insurance used a series of photographs to show, too, that darker cars are much harder to see in the half light of dawn and dusk when, unfortunately, many drivers don't turn on their lights.

The capacity for a car to be lost in its background depends, of course, on the colour of the car and the colour of the background. I've long argued that the most common background is the road itself, a bitumen surface that ranges in colour from silver to charcoal, and this camouflage effect is most dangerous when the car is approaching the looker. A typical instance of that occurs when the looker is waiting at a T intersection and the car is approaching on his right. This circumstance, I believe, puts cars that are silver, grey, charcoal and dark blue at greater risk of being involved in an accident, but despite many requests over a decade I've not been able to get the necessary help for such a study.

As I report in my column today, NRMA Insurance has just released the results of an examination of its own records to show that dark cars, and it mentions black, green and blue, are involved in 10 per cent more accidents that cars of lighter colours. As well, it found that the average cost of accident repairs for dark cars was higher than that for other cars, suggesting that these dark cars are involved in more serious accidents.

NRMA Insurance used a series of photographs to show, too, that darker cars are much harder to see in the half light of dawn and dusk when, unfortunately, many drivers don't turn on their lights.

Often it is movement, not the image, that alerts me to the approach of a car at an intersection, and I don't think it's a result of poor eyesight or attention. (Fingers crossed, I've never had an accident.) My theory is that it is mass, movement and contrast that goes to the visibility of a vehicle.

Do you agree that colour is an important component of a car's safety? Which colours do you see as the least and most visible?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I recently bought myself a motorcycle, and I have to say that it has given me an increased appreciation of just how important vehicle visibility is. It would be crazy to go out on the bike without a high-visibility vest or a reflective, light-coloured jacket... and driving a dark-coloured car really seems just as dangerous. Since I started riding, I've also made an effort to be more aware of the vehicles around me (both while driving and riding), and I have to say that certain cars make this difficult. I haven't actually had much of a problem with light-silver cars, but black, grey and other dark-coloured cars seem to disappear during the early morning and late afternoon. On the other hand, white, yellow and red cars seem to stand out. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that drivers of dark cars (and motorcycle riders who wear dark leathers) are more at risk. But it's not just an issue of their own personal risk, they make things much more difficult for all other road users.
Posted by Jim, 3/12/2008 6:37:20 PM
I don't think there is anything, Jim, that better teaches a driver to see and watch other vehicles than a motorbike. But in terms of visibility, ex-police bikes seem to be 100 times more visible than bikes of any colour.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 4/12/2008 11:29:11 AM
Oh don't you start Jeff......my dad (approaching a thousand years old) is always complaining about the colour of cars and how dangerous dark coloured cars are...... his least favourite colour is olive green/grey cars ....... I am pretty certain (statistics aside) that the capacity for accidents is more related to the idiot behind the wheel, and not the paintwork! I wonder whether there is a statistical correlation between idiot drivers and dark cars.......
Posted by King Idiot, 3/12/2008 6:47:21 PM
For best visibility under a range of lighting conditions including at night, I believe white is the way to go, or failing that, bright yellow. (Forgotten where I read this.) Another advantage of white is it is noticeably cooler, reflecting more heat (you can compare white against a car of any other colour by putting your hands on the external bodywork in the sun). Saves on the aircon (which then saves petrol). I always get white now for these reasons.
Posted by Chris, 3/12/2008 7:13:35 PM
Try seeing past a 4WD or MPV vehical that is parked on a corner. Deadly!
Posted by donald, 4/12/2008 1:57:02 PM
Another piece of camouflage are the "must have" clear indicator & brake lenses. When the sun is shining directly on the indicator you cannot tell if it is blinking or not....works a treat on roundabouts.
Posted by Steve, 4/12/2008 1:58:28 PM
All cars should be painted air-sea rescue orange or Penzoil yellow.
Posted by figjam, 10/12/2008 10:38:02 PM
Chris try seeing a white car in fog
Posted by Leopard girl, 22/12/2008 2:17:45 PM
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles

Travelworld_See the World
 
EAO_The Loop
 
 
Kloster No 1. Car Sale
 
Hamilton St Patricks Day
 
Scholarships
 
School Newspaper Competition
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...