Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Celebrity or fame 

Celebrity or fame

Carl Williams the drug dealer and serial killer became, in life, a celebrity, and now in death may be elevated to a modern-day bushranger. Were it not for television dramatisation he would have lived and died a sinister and sordid criminal whose trade was misery and death.

The peculiar distortions of television dramatisation have conferred celebrity on all who lived and died through Melbourne gangland's spray of bullets, and the script writers are waving their glamorising wand over Sydney's underworld now.

Australians seem to be suckers for the glorification of criminals. Serial killers, corrupt cops and the human cockroaches of the underworld develop a celebrity status that in some ways exceeds that of our national sport heroes. Since, I ask in my column today, serial killer and drug dealer Carl Williams became a celebrity, can the low-life junky slinking along our streets looking for a house to burgle look forward to that adulation if he's played in a TV series?

The series Underbelly and its elevation of criminals to the A-list has exposed the emptiness of celebrity. Do you, like me, see a difference between celebrity and fame? And do you agree that celebrity is the more respected in Australia?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Whats more concerning Jeff is that i think people are getting TV and reality mixed up. Do we blame all the reality TV for this? I dont know. But the amount of people writing RIP Carl Williams in their facebook status and all the RIP Carl Williams facebook groups popping up is unbelievable. Just because you saw a tv series with a charactor named Carl Williams does not mean you lived in his world, and does not mean you know him. It is sickening. Actually its quite concerning of the future and you can see it with the violence that seems to be pore prevelant today. More violence on TV, more violent computer games and it seems more and more people are getting fiction and reality confused.
Posted by Nafe, 21/04/2010 10:37:27 AM, on The Herald
My grandfather who was born in 1901 said he could never understand the admiration for a common criminal such as Ned Kelly.
Posted by Lucy, 21/04/2010 10:39:09 AM, on The Herald
Carl Williams, or any other thug, should not be glorified in any way, shape or form. The media are often responsible for making people famous or infamous. We want news reports but should we glamourise these peoples lifestyles? So many copy cat crims would seem to say that we shouldnt. When found guilty, Carl Williams should have been put to death. As should anyone found guilty of murder. Instead we are willing to cough up our taxes to feed and house this scum for years and years and years. I recall that it costs over one hundred thousand dollars a year to keep someone in jail. And then, when he gets killed in jail we are going to pay compensation to his daughter... and his wife is going to sell her story to a womens magazine for a quarter of a million dollars... we are so dumb. If there is absolutely no doubt about their guilt - execute them. If someone was to murder your loved one, how would you feel every time you get paid knowing that a little bit of your taxes was going to house and feed your loved ones killer? doesn't make sense to me. i know its not always black and white but in many cases it is.
Posted by judgedredd, 21/04/2010 10:39:16 AM, on The Herald
Carl Williams and his associates only made their money because of the prohibition of ecstasy in Australia, like those who made their fortunes in the US in the 1920's during the prohibition of alcohol. History will judge these people as people who continued to provide a drug the community demanded, and we will see the prohibition of ecstasy as a failure of governments past.
Posted by Justin, 21/04/2010 10:42:32 AM, on The Herald
reading about this carl williams bloke and his ex and the rest of their mates has been as interesting as watching grass grow. It unfortunately is what people want. Think 'ill go watch a kung fu movie
Posted by suzhousid, 21/04/2010 10:49:08 AM, on The Herald
Celebrity, whilst fleeting, tends to be in the here and now, we can touch and be a part of "it". Fame goes on forever. Williams and Co could only be considered "infamous" , just look at Roberta's cheap scramble to reconnect with her failed celebrity status. Once a moll always a moll. Hands up those that have EVER slowed down at a car accident? Cause your doing it now.
Posted by Bob G, 21/04/2010 10:57:54 AM, on The Herald
I think it's very sad that criminal grubs who profit from the misery of others are held up as celebrities - they may be "famous" for their escapades but it is the tabloid media and shows such as the underbelly series that encourages misplaced hero worship - why give these scum the time of day - if we treated the real heroes in our community to the same media promotion we may actually see a change in , particularly our youths , attitudes - by heroes I mean emergency services personnel , doctors and nurses , the countless community volunteers that help our society actually work. Good news stories are unfortunately too few these days.
Posted by smithy, 21/04/2010 10:59:39 AM, on The Herald
Wow, Jeff, you're really reeling them out this week... Williams was low-life scum. A brainless thug who made his money on other people's misery. I loathe the thousands of Facebook wannabes that write their messages of support for him and his ilk; all seeking some kind of fame by association themselves. It's a very sad cultural shift. Even comparing Ned Kelly and Carl Williams together is an abomination in my book. Yes Ned Kelly was a criminal, but his wronging by the justice system and opression by the law at the time pushed him there. Carl Williams willingly walked there out of greed
Posted by crusty, 21/04/2010 11:01:32 AM, on The Herald
Jeff I wouldn't say that Carl Williams became a celebrity through the tv show. I would say he gained a level of notoriety. John Ibrahim is another matter. I think he portrays himself as a celebrity (in gossip columns). The Underbelly show has certainly opened my eyes to the level of police corruption that was going on.
Posted by leahkf, 21/04/2010 11:01:56 AM, on The Herald
Such is the power of TV that common criminals are now looked up to by persons who have never been on the receiving end of their trade or viciousness - same deal with motor cycle outlaw gangs who fall a considerable distance from attaining Robin Hood status. About time the media began to portray these people for what they are instead of ensuring ratings.
Posted by MizJasper, 21/04/2010 11:41:43 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...