Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Family rifts 

Family rifts

The truth of what Kylie Agllias had to say about family estrangements was instantly obvious: problems with all manner of relationships between people were discussed, researched and addressed, but family estrangements remained unstudied. No doubt about it, the long-term bitter rifts that marr many families never seem to rate a mention. And yet we all know families, perhaps our own, with terrible estrangements.

As I write in my column today, Ms Agllias, a lecturer in social work at Newcastle University, is researching family estrangements as her PhD thesis and hoping parents estranged from a child (and over the age of 65) will phone her on 4921 7035. She has noticed in statistics from research into other issues that one in 40 people are estranged from a family member; statistics in one study suggest that 7 per cent of the population don't have contact with a parent.

There are many reasons for this separation. Divorce is a common one, and arguments over deceased estates another. Betrayal is a claim often made by one of the estranged, and Ms Agllias has found that often one of the estranged people has no idea of the reason. For some, she says, estrangement can be a relief, a respite from conflict.

I have known an estrangement that split a family down the middle, a mother, son and daughter on one side and the father and a son on the other. It was very sad, and so far as I could see based on nothing of any consequence, yet both parents died estranged from one or two of their children. It must have blighted their lives, and they were good and intelligent people.

Deathbed reconciliations are too late, but what can be done? Could government fund a scheme in which, at the request of an estranged family member, a social worker invited the other family member to mediation? Hopefully Ms Agllias's research will make the possibilities clear.

Tell us about your experience of estrangement, your own or observed.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Estrangement is sad. The thing that sets it off in the first place often becomes irrelevant over time but by then pride, hurt and the fear of rejection or embarrassment can override everything. This is where skilful mediators could come into their own. Those who dumped on all counsellors on a blog here the other day could reconsider their dismissive attitude. So many problems between people are down to poor self-awareness and poor communication skills. That's what good counsellors specialise in, and what many of us could learn, for the good of our own and our families' happiness.
Posted by Mel, 14/02/2009 4:12:26 PM
Arguments over deceased estates are common, as you point out Jeff, one farmer had a good succession plan (that can be applied to many situations) when he got one son to divide the farm and assest equally with the condition the other son got first choice. Good to have a plan in place that has been discussed and agreed before you die, it's hard to rule from the grave. Plenty of rain about for farmers' planning an autumn pasture sowing, are you planting any spuds Jeff?
Posted by chaff and oats, 14/02/2009 7:58:44 PM
Don't grow potatoes, chaff and oats, because I leave the garden to rest over winter and I want the space to plant spring vegies very early. Jeff
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 17/02/2009 7:47:49 AM
They can always get counselling Jeff. A lecturer in social work sounds similarly useless to me.
Posted by moron, 16/02/2009 6:01:16 AM
Yes, everyone I know seems to have an estrangement in their family. Perhaps it comes down to you can choose your friends but not your family. Luckily My family are extremely close and supportive, except for my eldest brother. Unfortunately we have to enforce/endure an estrangement due to his mental illness. We as a family have tried everything you could possibly imagine to help him and have repeatedly turned to every government and health body for help. However, his right to be mentally ill out weighs his right to a normal life. This is a severely ill man who is also estranged from his two adult children. They and the rest of our family maintain no contact with him now for our own physical safety and emotional health. He breaks the law quite a bit and nothing ever happens because he is ill. Our mental health laws in Australia are such that a mentally ill person has the right to live without treatment and therefore lives a very sad and tragic life. He is a sad and angry man with no joy in his life, he can't enjoy his siblings, children or grandchild. And yes I do blame our governments for failing him as a human being.
Posted by leahkf, 16/02/2009 7:19:35 AM
Hello Leahkf. Very sad. And I do question the new "right to be mentally ill". Can they make a rational decision? I wonder if it is the health authorities opting out.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 17/02/2009 7:46:38 AM
When I say 'right to be mentally ill' - it seems the authorities will not enforce any sort of treatment - unless of course that person commits murder, rape or some other awful crime. Meanwhile people like my brother live tortured lonely lives. He has no idea how to connect with other people in an appropriate manner. I would love for my 'old' brother to be back, the loving kind gentle person I remember but I believe the illness has taken hold so strongly now and he is so buried in the mire that even if they did enforce treatment now, he wouldn't recover. It is a tragedy of epic proportions that has played out for about 20 years now - anyway off the subject of estrangements......
Posted by leahkf, 18/02/2009 7:05:50 AM
p.s. the irony is, Last year a nearby neighbour who had always been odd, decided to pick me to carry out his delusions. He is clearly mentally ill, and it is obvious that he is estranged from his family (and society), and he is slowly forcing the estrangement of his partner and two little children. No matter how much I despise him and wish he would just go away and leave me alone (now that I have taken out an avo, he seems to be - a whole other story), I still feel immensely sorry for him and his kids. As quite obviously they will never form a family unit.
Posted by leahkf, 18/02/2009 7:10:22 AM
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

Travelworld_See the World
 
School Newspaper Competition


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...