Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Family tree futility 

Family tree futility

Is there anything as pointless as compiling a family tree? We've all been waylaid by women gushing about their family research, about finding that an ancestor was a cabin boy on the Titanic or some such silliness, and like me you may have wished that they'd stuck with knitting to keep themselves occupied.

You've seen the TV show, Who do you think you are?, and the tears, you've heard people say they're compiling "their story", how they feel complete now that they've discovered where they came from, and you've wondered whethered you've missed out on something. You have - it's called the silly gene.

These people are desperately seeking royalty, and if that fails anyone recorded in history for any reason will do. Some will even tell you that they feel sometimes that they are a particular person (usually a notable one), and you might like to ask them if they've found themselves speaking 9olde English or another forgotten tongue.

The fact that they may share no genes with the ancestor is not a problem, and nor is the fact that their lineage, their pedigree, is almost certainly rendered false by an empty claim to fatherhood somewhere. One in 10 children, researchers say, has been fathered by someone other than the man who believes he is the father, and while I don't believe that I do believe the rate is high enough to render every family tree mortally flawed.

And what, anyway, does your ancestry have to do with who you are? And you with them? There can be nothing to be proud of in having a great great great great grandfather who was a king or a peasant.

Many who delve into genealogy are, it seems to me, seeking to established that they are pedigreed, and if the notion of being a pure-bred person seems absurd consider the great pride taken by those who call themselves First Fleeters, who claim to be descendants of someone who arrived in Sydney Cove with the First Fleet on 26 January 1788.

Many have no reason to be proud of their ancestor’s arrival as a criminal and convict, and many were not expelled from Britain for merely stealing an apple, but it is really the pedigree that fuels the vanity.

They’ll tell you with pride that they are 10th generation Australian, and some do seem to believe that this gives their opinions greater weight, when I cannot see that they have anything more to be proud of than an Australian who arrived five years ago, or, for that matter, a stateless refugee.

Is family history something to be proud of? Hasn't modern man moved on from ancestor worship?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I have no interest in my dad or his side of the family (its a boring name anyway), but for some reason they were all excited when my brother got a girl pregnant at 17 and could 'pass on the name'. As if there werent enough of us already.

My mums side might have been a little more interesting with close generational links to Isaac Newton and Lord Kelvin (I hate mathematics, but the scientist in them held some appeal). But my aunt, the only one interested in this crap, discovered that my grandfather adopted the name in his identity. Not really a Kelvin and couldnt care less.

Posted by Danielle, 29/11/2011 8:13:31 AM, on The Herald
Most people study Geneology as a hobby, its not much different to going bike riding or playing golf.

The satisfaction comes not from the social position or otherwise of the ancestor, as from the sence of satisfaction in solving a mystery.

It's a "who dun it" with real people, the goal is to find enough official documentation to prove a link before chasing the next generation back.


Posted by FED UP, 29/11/2011 8:16:59 AM, on The Herald
There is a certain attraction in exploring the mystery, I agree. The work, though, seems to be tedious.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/11/2011 9:02:22 AM
I know where I come from.

I can name an ancestor with the same name from the Middle Ages from a specific place.

Why is it that White Europeans are discouraged from knowing who they are?

Posted by Laurie Brewster maclaurie@hotmail.com Skype Video aussie9999red <>, 29/11/2011 8:26:31 AM, on The Herald
Hello Jeff, Every pastime has its merciless earbashers with no idea that their obsession is totally uninteresting to their victims. I have been a keen family researcher for decades but, hopefully, observe the cardinal rule of keeping your mouth shut. I am sorry you have been subjected to these deluded people - but, I hasten to say, not entirely women. I know. As for hoping for royalty, tell them that there is a family history story that everyone of English extraction is descended from one of the Plantagent kings by his multiple liaisons etc. That should get them off your back for a while.
Posted by Elaine, 29/11/2011 8:28:05 AM, on The Herald
What interesting snippets have you discovered in your family history, Elaine?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/11/2011 9:03:25 AM
You can tell I am an illegitimate bastard son of a whore just by looking at me. Just looking at my brothers and sisters you can tell there was a mix up in the hospital or I was adopted.
Posted by judgedredd, 29/11/2011 9:00:39 AM, on The Herald
But judge what if your hoary mother was bedded by ,say a Rothchild or a Rockafella or even Elvis. Now that would be worth knowing.
Posted by horse, 29/11/2011 9:43:48 AM, on The Herald
I am proud to say that in my family tree I am a descendant from the Frasers of Scotland, but I am more proud of my convict ancestors, five in all, who landed on these shores twenty years after settlement. Along with my Irish immigrants they built this land and made it a great country. Yes! and I also have illigitimate children, law breakers and even mental illness and suicide. But thats life!
Posted by LynD, 29/11/2011 9:44:40 AM, on The Herald
How many generations have you been able to track back, Lyn?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/11/2011 9:51:05 AM
I love the sound of knitting neadles in the morning..

what's that smell? is that a third ernie in the wind?

Posted by catlocker, 29/11/2011 10:01:25 AM, on The Herald
God feeds the Ravens is the motto of the Corbett family according to a quick search of the net. The site revealed the noble and distinguished Corbett family emerged from the historical and enchanting region of Normandy. Sounds ever so nice ! But we know Jeff 's line is from a bushranger's fling!
Posted by chaff and oats, 29/11/2011 10:15:52 AM, on The Herald
Excuse me, chaffnoats, but Captain Thunderbolt's association with Mary Ann Bugg was no fling!
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/11/2011 10:20:59 AM
In the words of Henry Ford, "History is bunk".
Posted by Steve, 29/11/2011 10:35:23 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles




Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...