Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Food intolerances 

Food intolerances

My wife has what appears to be a severe intolerance of MSG and related glutamates used as flavour enhancers, and dozens of times I've listened as she questions waiters or kitchen staff about the components of certain dishes on the menu. I have been amazed by the willingness of waiters and cooks to give easy, and very probably false, assurances, to the point that I urge my wife not to ask. Word from the cook that there is no MSG in any of the ingredients of a dish is almost certainly wrong, given that added MSG or related glutamates are in so many of the processed ingredients. "No MSG in the crumbed calamari love," the cook shouted from the door of the kitchen in a northern NSW club a year ago, and some little time later my wife went off to hospital in an ambulance. We know, now, that MSG is in crumb mixes, and stocks, seasonings, salad dressings, sauces and so many other standard ingredients.

In only one eatery has the cook warned that he or she could not guarantee the absence of MSG or other prolematic additives in any dish, and that occurred on Saturday night. This cook generously prepared my wife a dish from scratch, which makes my admission today that I'd not want anyone with serious intolerances in my restaurant rather miserable. I mean, is a $30 or $100 sale worth the risk of bankrupting litigation? And given the proliferation of food additives today can anyone give a guarantee that a dish does not contain an allergen?

The difficulty faced by people who have an intolerance of nuts has been exacerbated, I've noticed, by what appears to be the standard practice now of including a nuts warning on so many processed foods. Not only is it that this product contains nuts, it may contain nuts, it may contain traces of nuts, it may have been prepared with equipment that may previously have prepared a product that may have contained traces of nut!

The food-processing industry is doing what I'd consider doing as a restaurateur. MSG can give you a heart attack? Yes, every dish is riddled with the stuff - try the restaurant next door.

Anaphylaxis Australia, an organisation established to help people with life-threatening allergies, tells me this blanket declaration is a problem. It has, it says, been negotiating with food manufacturers to introduce a more consistent and realistic declaration of the presence of allergens. I'll be surprised, though, if manufacturers are prepared to reduce their protection from litigation in favour of the needs of potential litigants.

It is a problem. Do you have allergies or food intolerances? How do you fare beyond your own kitchen?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
What the hell is MSG anyway?! There is an asian food store in Hunter St that sells it in 10kg bags!! So if all these restaurants don't use it - who exactly is buying these 10 kg bags?! The stuff should be banned. Horrid muck.
Posted by White Crystal Garbage, 20/10/2009 8:04:59 AM, on The Herald
Here is a feature article written by a Stevenson Swanson and published in The Herald in April:

It's the "mmmmmmm " in meat, the pizazz in a pepperoni pizza. It's what makes people cheer for cheese.

It's "umami", and if your reaction is "u-what-ee?" you've got plenty of company. But not for long.

Chefs, nutritionists, cookbook authors and food manufacturers are salivating over the merits of umami, the so-called "fifth taste" that is neither salty, sweet, bitter or sour.

An increasing awareness of the umami quotient in food is giving everyone who cooks, from high-end chefs to home cooks, greater understanding of how adding umami flavours can perk up their culinary creations.

Nutritionists see the potential for umami to help people eat better, especially populations such as the elderly whose sense of taste may be impaired. And for food processors, boosting umami levels in their products could mean less reliance on salt, or more palatable low-sodium products.

"If we can be aware of what it is, we're going to have better-tasting food all the time," said David Kasabian, co-author of The Fifth Taste: Cooking with Umami, which he says is the first cookbook devoted to the subject.

Umami pronounced "oo-MA-mee" comes from a Japanese word meaning "deliciousness." This somewhat elusive flavour shows up in a wide variety of protein-rich foods.

It is the satisfying savour that makes people crave steak. It is the gratifying richness of grated parmesan cheese. It is the deep, comforting taste of a bowl of chicken soup.

"Yummy' is another way of saying it," said Jacqueline Marcus, a nutritionist and food consultant. "It's that salivating, lip-smacking character."

This savory taste was isolated 100 years ago by Kikunae Ikeda, a Japanese scientist who wanted to figure out what gave dashi, a Japanese seaweed soup, its distinct flavour.

Ikeda concluded that the umami flavour came from glutamate, an amino acid and protein building-block.

That means protein-rich foods such as meat and dairy products tend to be high in umami, especially when the cooking or processing of the foods gives the proteins time to break down into glutamates.

Curing, aging, browning and slow-cooking enhance the umami taste of those foods.

Although the concept has been around for a century, the fifth taste has been slow to catch on in other Western countries. For starters, there's the name, a strange-sounding foreign word.

Also, many food experts and scientists long assumed that umami was merely a combination of some of the four established tastes.

In contrast to them, "umami tastes aren't found as separate tastes," said University of Miami research scientist Nirupa Chaudhari, a specialist in the biophysics of taste. "Lemons have a very isolated sour taste. Fruit quite often has a very isolated sweet taste. Seawater has an isolated salt taste. So maybe that's why umami wasn't as well understood."

Chaudhari and her colleagues put to rest any lingering doubts about umami's status as a separate taste in 2000, when they isolated a receptor on taste buds that responds to the amino acids that impart umami flavour.

And humans are not alone in having a taste for umami. All the mammals studied so far have umami receptors, Chaudhari says. In fact, members of the cat family lack sweet receptors but have very strong sensitivity to umami, perhaps reflecting the fact that they are exclusively meat-eaters.

Chefs are increasingly incorporating umami flavours into their recipes. New York's Jean-Georges Vongerichten makes a custard with Gruyere, goat and Parmesan cheeses, topped with shaved black truffle. He calls it "an umami bomb."

And Chicago's Rick Bayless, chef-owner of the Frontera Grill and Topolobampo, recently offered an $US85 ($93) four-course umami tasting menu.

Among the items on the menu, which he billed as a "journey through deliciousness," were a duck salad with grilled onions and shiitake mushrooms, both of which are high in umami, and a grass-fed ribeye steak with a potato-and-cheese accompaniment and, for good measure, some bacon.

"My favourite umami ingredient," notes Bayless, adding that the umami dinner was his best-selling tasting menu during the past four weeks. "I think if you're a food professional and you don't know about umami, you're not very aware."

Bayless, who opened Frontera Grill in 1987, first read about umami in a restaurant trade journal about 10 years ago. As he came across more references to it, he delved more deeply into the subject because it helped explain why certain dishes have an immediate allure for diners.

"Foods that are high in sugar, or high in acid, or high in bitter tend to be more polarising," he says. "Umami is that flavour to which almost everyone is attracted, immediately and forever."

Food companies have been aware of umami for decades, even if they didn't know the word. One of the standby additives in processed food is some form of monosodium glutamate, or MSG, a flavour enhancer that is a kind of essence of umami.

But MSG came under a cloud in the 1980s, when it was linked to "Chinese restaurant syndrome," the headaches, fevers or other reactions that some people claimed were the result of eating food loaded with MSG, which some Chinese restaurants used with abandon.

Since then, rigorous scientific studies have cleared MSG of being the culprit, according to Kasabian, the cookbook author.

Even so, recognising that consumers remain suspicious of MSG, giant food companies such as Campbell Soup and Nestle are experimenting with ways to cut the salt content of food without losing flavour or adding more MSG. That can mean adding umami-rich ingredients such as cheese, mushrooms or anchovy powder, or using newly developed artificial flavours that do not contain MSG.

Marcus, the nutritionist, believes that foods with increased umami flavours could counteract the decline in the sense of taste that occurs with aging.

With a duller sense of taste, many older people lose interest in eating, opening the way to malnutrition, dangerous weight loss and vulnerability to disease.

And because umami flavours soften the bitterness of foods, some nutritionists think that an understanding of umami could lead to healthier diets for children, who have a heightened sensitivity to bitter flavours, leading to an aversion to many vegetables.

"No food is nutritious unless that food is eaten, and no food is eaten unless it tastes good," Marcus says. "And umami makes food taste good."

"Yummy is another way of saying it ... It's that salivating, lip-smacking character."


Posted by Jeff Corbett on 20/10/2009 8:32:06 AM
You only had to watch Gordon Ramsay Hells Kitchen to see how waiters will BS about anything/everything. "Is this soup/fish/ etc fresh?" "Oh yes!" (fresh out of a sealed container). You can't believe anything they say so I no longer bother asking.
Posted by Tono, 20/10/2009 8:07:41 AM, on The Herald
I think "MSG FREE" in most of these places means you don't have to pay for it. Ghastly stuff. Emperor Ming would have had the heads of whomever developed that powdered crap.
Posted by NO MSG EVER!, 20/10/2009 8:17:16 AM, on The Herald
thankfully I'm not allergic to any foods, however when I do happen to eat something with msg it makes be incredibly thirsty. However it is never quenched, so I end up drinking litres of water. So I avoid msg if at all possible. While pregnant I read some reports & was told by some medical staff to avoid peanuts if I had a common allergy (I'm allergic to dust, dustmites etc.). as there is emerging evidence of a link between the mum having allergies, eating too many peanut products & baby being allergic to peanuts. I wasnt so dedicated to eliminate food with possible peanut traces, but I didn't eat peanuts & peanut paste. Jeff we harvested cauliflower, silverbeet & carrots on the weekend from our winter plantings (yep not many carrots germinated). We recharged the vegie patch with cow poo & compost & planted eggplant, bush beans, cucumber. Then dotted around the rest of the garden in amongst flowers I've put tomatoes, lettuce, rocket & corn along the fence. Plus we just planted a panama red passionfruit vine along one fence. And the mango (kensington pride) tree has lots of little mangos Last year's crop was only 2, but the year before was 24. We are hoping for a bumper!
Posted by leahkf, 20/10/2009 8:33:03 AM, on The Herald
I hope latina fresh checks the labels on the pasta sauce bottles. havent heard from latina for a while? has he suffered a msg overdose?
Posted by senior sergeant smith, 20/10/2009 8:38:52 AM, on The Herald
A good restaurant should make stocks from scratch, which is the base of all soups and sauces. Any food establishment that has msg present in it's food is selling commercially made frozen crap. Good quality food needs no enhancing.
Posted by Chef Dude, 20/10/2009 8:44:43 AM, on The Herald
"Glutamate is found naturally in foods such as tomatoes, mushrooms, broccoli, peas, cheese, meats, fish, even human milk (20 times more than cow's milk)." Are people who are MSG intolerant able to tolerate these foods ok?
Posted by notashrink, 20/10/2009 8:44:48 AM, on The Herald
When it is added it is usually added in quantities much greater than those that occur naturally.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 20/10/2009 8:52:55 AM
Snr Sgt Smth - I may be laying low but I do check JC's blog every day - (I might have other pseudonyms I use) - like the Genie in the Lamp, Latina only comes out when summoned. For your edification, I don't go in for MSG or artificial stimulants. The only stimulants I need is some soft music, soft candlelight, an uncorked bottle of Dom Perignon and a coquettish, but consenting and of age, bottle of Dolmio. Let's not make the matter sordid by introducing chemical enhancement.
Posted by Latina Fresh, 20/10/2009 9:01:04 AM, on The Herald
I think that I would provoke an outrage f I put forward the proposition that MSG used properly is no more harmful than mothers milk is on a baby. I would also enhance that rage by suggesting sodium in the form of salt is responsible for a genocide quatum of damage on humans and that is tolerated. Then if I were to suggest that MSG may be blamed in instances when it is not responsible, is irresponsibly used and also part of a seriously wrong diet and lifestyle anyway. Then I can hear the irish answers fuming away before the keys get bashed. I think that this may have got you going last post -or someone did and you didnt list their post. I know about the dangers of certain intolerances of foods and substances - i will die if given morphine as a pain killer. I know that because of the direct clinical cause and effect was established clearly (in the total absence of everything else) So is MSG the same for some? If so then they must stay away from those things that are dangerous for them. I dont advocate taking opiates off the prescription medicine list because of my unique metabolism. Salt, alcohol, smoking and prawns kill ! sorry- unbalanced, hypocritical and maladjusted argument!
Posted by a..shole, 20/10/2009 9:07:24 AM, on The Herald
I have a violent allergy. I react badly to substandard tucker, especially if the bill is likely to be a hefty one. Chef Dude - totally agree. Most kitchens could improve their risk profile AND their food by making their own stocks, sauces, etc. How many still take shortcuts? Many, I reckon. I noticed a small, very elegant looking gold tin in a Sydney Chinatown grocery the other day : "Gourmet Powder". Contents? 100% pure MSG....... *sigh*
Posted by Abundance, 20/10/2009 9:15:21 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

School Newspaper Competition
 
Travelworld_See the World


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...