Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Hurtling towards calamity 

Hurtling towards calamity

If a giant meteorite were assessed by scientists to be hurtling through space in our general direction with a one in one thousand chance of slamming into our planet we'd be making frantic preparations. The probability might be low but the consequence so severe that people the world over would be pulling out all stops to ensure their own, their nation's and mankind's survival. Imagine the scurry if the probability of collision was one in 100.

The chances of climate change seriously affecting the world and man's capacity to feed and water himself within the lifetime of people alive now is much higher than one in 100. And the consequences for everyone would be severe, even for those who find themselves fortuitously in a valley of plenty. Yet preparations are at best relaxed.

Climate change is happening, and our capacity to keep that in check is the subject of debate. But the world has the capacity to reduce its impact on our food and water systems, yet even this insurance seems to be dismissed as something someone else should do, as something we don't need to do. Australians believe we're sitting pretty, apart from those living on the waterfront.

I insure my car despite the fact that I've never had an accident and I think the risk is low. Bridges are built to withstand loads much greater than they'll ever carry. Cars are insured and bridges are over-engineered because the consequences of calamity are severe.

Yet Australians and people of other developed nations seem to have a mental block when it comes to the unsustainability of our way of life. Even small changes are seen as too hard. And government-enforced change is precarious in a democracy.

Are we doomed by our own inertia and intransigence? What can be done to create change?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Before the meteorite hits i thought i would enquire about the welfare of senior sergeant smith who has been missing for a few days. i recall you were lame and i hope you have been able to recover in time to take evasive action.
Posted by chaff and oats, 18/06/2009 12:00:49 PM
But there are a lot of people who should know better who state that climate change is a myth... also people who say cigarettes don't damage your health and the world is only 900 years old. When the meteorite is on it's way, there will be people who will say it doesn't exist or won't harm us at all. It's the "we'll be right" syndrome.
Posted by stevo, 18/06/2009 1:21:59 PM
Most people are generally effort-averse when it comes to the environment or sustainability even when you frame it in terms of it directly benefiting their children's future. Most people think in the short term as you point out Jeff - they don't think long term and they don't tend to notice incremental changes. There is always a big kerfuffle when petrol prices jump sharply before a holiday weekend but it is never matched when they increase to the same levels more gradually. Therefore why would you expect people to behave any differently as the world gradually warms, and the seas gradually rise and acidify, and biodiversity gradually alters? There is probably only about 15% of the population who are REALLY concerned about sustainability AND are doing something serious about it in their day to day lives. I imagine the rest will wait until the meteorite arrives on the horizon before they do anything about it - and then they will probably expect someone else to do something about it!
Posted by Mulga Bill, 18/06/2009 1:50:37 PM
Jeff, if you get 20 people together for a BBQ, someone will be condemning man made climate change as a myth. I have listened to these doubters, and have come to the conclusion they just like being the odd man out, knowing something that the rest of us just do not get. As for fixing the situation, we have the answers but not the will power. I think it will have to be so far gone before we get anything but token efforts and speeches from world leaders. Of course it is much more important to be re-elected than to save the planet, ask Peter Garrett he is toeing the line so well i think someone told him he would make PM. The other thing that amuses me is why haven't the youth of today started to protest loudly. Instead as a group they are so into themselves, consuming anything at all, using power like it is their destiny. It is their next 70 years that is going to be highly affected, why are they stagnant and accepting of the climate change issue. I am sure i will get the old crap of baby boomers recking the world, but that does not excuse the youth of today standing up, even if they turned lights off now and then it may help.
Posted by Buell, 18/06/2009 2:01:49 PM
A Jeff, good to see you've succumbed to Global Warmthink - where the hyperbole increases daily. Soon we will be told that unless we invent a time machine and go back to 1977 so we can reduce 1977 carbon emissions to 45% of 1952 levels, we will be doomed with 15 degree temperature increases and beachfront property in Katoomba. Humans love apocalyptic fervour - consider just the last few decades: Nuclear annihilation, Y2K, peak oil, ebola, chook flu, SARS, pig flu, global warming (now called "climate change" - gotta hedge our bets in case it gets cooler), ad infinitum, ad absurdum. I'd rate the risk of a Zombie apocalypse as greater than the risk of global warmthink ecological collapse. Besides, plenty of planets left in the cosmos. If this one really does start to fall apart, we might pull our fists out and get busy exploring the stars.
Posted by Scott Hillard, 18/06/2009 2:06:41 PM
Actually Scott Hillard climate change and global warming are two different (but related) things! The global atmosphere IS warming (for whatever reason) and the climate around the world IS changing (for whatever reason). Arguing over the mechanisms behind these readily and scientifically observable situations is the tool used by those folk who have an interest in not changing anything, be they individuals or organisations. They seek to confuse and befuddle the community into a state of unquestioning inertia. It would therefore appear that the zombie apocalypse has already begun.
Posted by Mulga Bill, 18/06/2009 3:00:35 PM
Mulga Bill -excuse me for being “difficult”, but isn't discovering the mechanism behind global warming/climate change vitally important to determine if indeed it is resulting from human activity, and therefore if any changes in human behaviour can influence the course as a result. I suspect that perhaps we do influence the climate in a small way, but not of great significance. Natural events such as volcanic eruptions have and will change the composition of the atmosphere and the climate much more immediately and dramatically than anything we seem to be observing from human activity. The eruptions of Krakatoa is a case in point. It has been postulated that the rapid cooling of the earth in 535-536 were as a result of a massive eruption of this volcano. There were similarly lower temperatures as a result of the dust plume after the eruption in 1883, with an average global temperature drop of 1.3 degress, and unsettled weather patterns for many years afterwards. Natural forces will far outstrip mankind in terms of climatic change/global warming. Just wait for the next big volcano to go bang
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 18/06/2009 3:23:37 PM
DS the difference between 535AD and now is about 100,000 coal fired power stations, we are gradually creating our own Krakatoa. And even if you and others disagree what is wrong with reducing pollution? While ever persons minimise the human contribution to Global Warming the multi national companies and governments will do nothing. So for your childrens sake, you better be right, your betting their life on it.
Posted by Buell, 18/06/2009 5:22:55 PM
Buell - I have nothing at all against reducing pollution (I ride a bike everywhere -remember, and am quite the greenie in many other ways) - I was merely providing examples of real, severe NATURAL climate change, which far exceed anything even possibly attributable to man to date, and could conceivably happen tomorrow, and there is nothing we can do to stop it. I believe the science of climate change is equivocal at best, particularly given the confounders of natural events. One fact is indisputable –fossil fuels are finite and there is pressing need to alternatives, but to suggest that “climate change” is proven is I believe misleading –and may prove counter productive in tackling the real problem of diminishing fossil fuel reserves.
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 18/06/2009 6:00:23 PM
Great article Jeff! Unfortunately I believe we are, at best, in for a rough ride ahead and the longer that policy is stalled and a minority of skeptics are acknowledged instead of an overwhelming majority then I can see no happy ending in sight. Of course individuals can make steps towards reducing their 'carbon footprint' (and should) but it is with the industry where real changes have to be made. Ha Ha Scott are you suggesting that it would be easy just to move to another planet instead of making steps to fix this one. I'm curious which planet would we go to ?. How would we move an entire population of even Newcastle to this magic planet? Also DS even though a single eruption might change the climate, how often does this happen, If you were to take the impact of volcanoes over the last 300 years and compare that to the impact of man made pollution (on a year to year basis) the impact of volcanoes if next to nothing compared to that of industry. And for those that say the planet has been through this before, well yes it has but these changes have occurred over a million years or so, not hundreds, and yes the planet might fix itself, the usual way it does, extinction. Until people look at all the facts and not just the convenient ones I fear there is little hope
Posted by Tartan Dove, 18/06/2009 6:31:10 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles

Travelworld_See the World
 
EAO_The Loop
 
 
Kloster No 1. Car Sale
 
Hamilton St Patricks Day
 
Scholarships
 
School Newspaper Competition
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...