Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Love corrupted 

Love corrupted

Chinese people, I read while I was on holidays with the woman I appreciate, rate striving together as the key ingredient of marriage while Australians see love as the essential ingredient. This issues from a Queensland University examination of why divorce is so rare in China but so common in Australia, and it is clear that this notion of love is the culprit. This particular love, romantic love, has been created and promoted by the fiction industry to the point that now pretty well every work of fiction, be it a song or a novel or a movie, is riddled with romance.

And what better day for me to point out the stupidity of it all than today! Valentine's Day is part of the western scam that is romance, and in my column in the Herald today I warn that a marriage emanating from a proposal today is more likely than one from a proposal tomorrow to end in divorce. Indeed, if the Chinese experience is a fair guide Australians would be much happier and more successful in marriage if they proposed on the eighth of the eighth month, because in Chinese the word eight sounds like the word for wealth.

Romantic love is infatuation, rank with impossible expectations, and since those expections are about the happiness of only the infatuated person it is selfish. For that reason alone it is doomed. Of course expiring infatuation can be replaced by an appreciation, which is much more likely to sustain a marriage, and I deliberately don't use the word love because it has been so corrupted.

Do you join me in warning the swooning fools against proposing today? Or proposing on any day? Have you been a victim of the concoction that is romantic love?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Hi Jeff, great to see you back.

Guys who are overly romantic scare me, they always seem a touch delusional, plus I worry that I'd never live up to their expectations as in the long term the rose coloured glasses always come off.

That being said, kind gestures, that come without the fanfare are always appreciated - a bunch of flowers, taking care of dinner, always lovely.

Posted by daisy_k, 14/02/2012 5:16:12 AM, on The Herald
Hello Daisy. It's almost good to be back!
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 7:45:21 AM
Friendship and fairness is all important. Be fair to each other - it doesn't matter who does what, in the union, as long as you both agree and support each other.

Don't have children, unless you are willing to have your lives overturned by really committing to their upbrining. It's a big challenge.

Most so called "love", is simply "lust". But, I agree, the word "love" is over-rated. Nothing wrong with lust, it's part of the union.

Valentines day is trash - every day is an opportunity to tell someone how much they mean to you. Not 1 day a year!

Posted by Kurri'nRose, 14/02/2012 5:16:27 AM, on The Herald
The agree bit seems a bit much Rose. And I'm with you on the children - much more demanding than young people realise and in most cases are ready for.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 7:47:08 AM
What amuses me is that people who get divorced decide to marry someone else. They have previously demonstrated that they lack judgement and should never be trusted to make a decision on another person ever again. Marriage is a once-only event; only the death of a spouse should be grounds for re-marrying.
Posted by moron, 14/02/2012 6:08:36 AM, on The Herald
I am always puzzled when people of mature age marry for a second time. Why bother?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 7:48:45 AM
Apparently love has the same chemical reaction as an overload of chocolate.Hence the love lorn diving into the Cadbury's every time an affair goes pear shaped.

I have attended a couple of Chinese weddings lately ....what a hoot! and yes Jeff, I do think in China it is often about striving together, or, more to the point, both partners chasing the almighty dollar (RMB). In China the parents still have a big say in who you can marry. However, it is starting to change a bit with the younger generation getting a bit more independence

I am an A grade cynic when it comes to the subject of love.

Posted by sid, 14/02/2012 6:44:01 AM, on The Herald
You and most men, I suspect, sid, although few will admit it in intimate company. Is all well with you in China? Any adventures over the New Year break?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 7:51:10 AM
Your holiday does not seem to have improved your limited powers of reason Mr Corbett. You appear to want to differentiate between 'romantic' love & some other form of 'authentic' love yet completely fail to describe the difference. 'Love' may be an amorphous term but it is not in any way equivalent in meaning to 'appreciate'. Or is the real subtext of this article that you are just incapable of being in love with another person, Mr Corbett?
Posted by Hank Williams, 14/02/2012 7:26:27 AM, on The Herald
Did Mrs Corbett tell you how much she appreciates you at the breakfast table this morning Jeff ?
Posted by chaff and oats, 14/02/2012 8:48:24 AM, on The Herald
No, but she did give me a bill to pay and she told me she was looking forward to an excursion during the day. Don't forget to tell us about the clairvoyant!
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 9:36:21 AM
@moron - I would never consider remarrying. But having company and a friendship is quite acceptable.

I (personally) always considered marraige as a union to create a family and raise children etc. And hoped it was an "always" thing.

But that does not always work out, despite someone's best efforts. Sometimes one's sanity and the effort to protect the kids you love, become the preference to living a disturbed life.

I lasted 26 years. I gave it my best shot.

Having your own place and sharing time together, is a great idea.

Posted by Kurri'nRose, 14/02/2012 8:50:39 AM, on The Herald
Or is this just another plea for help, Mr Corbett?
Posted by Hank Williams, 14/02/2012 9:01:55 AM, on The Herald
Finally! I was worried you might have retired Jeff. What a good topic to start the year. I do think people expect too much from relationships and struggle to recognise the ever changing nature of love. Perhaps the problem is monogamy or expecting everything from 1 person. I think your right in identifying the difference between romantic love and long term relationships but it is different for everyone I suppose. Even tho romantic love may not be sustainable it certainly is great when your in it the trick is recreating it within the relationship because it certainly puts a spring in your step.
Posted by peterk, 14/02/2012 9:24:37 AM, on The Herald
Romance, I say, is ephemeral, unsustainable. I wonder, Peter, if the impossible expectations of marriage is a modern thing created by fiction writers.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 14/02/2012 9:40:38 AM
Welcome back Jeff!

St Valentine's Day is just a silly guilt trip that retailers and marketers use to make money. Imagine if someone was to meet another on 15 February and silly enough wait until 14 February of the following year to show their "love".

I would think only the naive would marry for romantic love alone. The person you fall in love with needs to be your friend as well.

Nice to see moron and Hank have been pining for your return!

Posted by justme, 14/02/2012 9:27:01 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles




Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...