Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Mental health prejudice 

Mental health prejudice

Government funding of mental health services has been in the news lately, although not for the reasons those in the industry would prefer. First up was the shock resignation of the federal government's mental health adviser, Professor John Mendoza, in protest against a lack of funding. And this week in The Sydney Morning Herald Australian of the Year Pat McGorry argued that such common terms as nutter and psycho reflected a prejudice that may explain the federal government's refusal to meet the huge demand for mental health services. Yesterday Professor McGorry, who is professor of youth mental health at Melbourne University, added that these widely held prejudices had insulated the federal government from criticism for its failing the mentally ill.

On reading that I examined my own use of such terms, for the first time in my life. My descriptions of people as a nutter or a loony or a fruitcake does betray prejudice, and it seems to me that our use of these and other terms serves only to reinforce our shared prejudices. One aspect of these descriptions has occurred to me before, and that is that once a person is deemed to be a nutter they are a nutter all the time and for ever more! A person who has had a psychotic episode is a psycho always, a person whose schizophrenia is successfully treated is nonetheless a schizo. Terrible!

It interests me that this disparaging applies to another mental state over which we have no control, that of intelligence. Among, for example, the responses on this blog you may have noticed people seeking to insult me by accusing me of not being intelligent. So what if I'm not as intelligent as they think I should be? Or as intelligent as they are?

I cannot see why anyone should be a lesser person because they are of below-average intelligence or are mentally ill. And I can't explain why we seem to find a satisfaction in denigrating these people. Can you?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
It makes people feel superior to belittle someone they feel is inferior or has an inferior trait. you dumb ranga.......
Posted by judgedredd, 25/06/2010 8:46:00 AM, on The Herald
Careful. As Julia said at the end of her interview with Kerry on 7.30 Report last night, it was a good day for redheads. We're arising.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 25/06/2010 10:03:16 AM
judgedreed - weren't you the bloke who helped get rid of the "No one thinks big of you" little finger/RTA campaign because it personally offended you? Don't be ashamed of what of what god gave (or in your case, didn't) you.
Posted by Erik the Red, 25/06/2010 10:11:07 AM, on The Herald
I would like to think of myself as somewhat intellectual..... but I also would like to think that I would never belittle someone else based on what I 'think' of their intelligence. I think when most people belittle others it is done so based on level of education more than anything else. I have a few friends who left school in early high school and I certainly don't feel 'better' than them. One of them is also illiterate, however he is an extremely intelligent man, and I always feel a bit dumb when around him. Whether someone is a black C--- or a bit of a nutter, we will always find ways to make ourselves feel superior. It must be human nature to make fun of others or to elevate ourselves through derision of others.
Posted by leahkf, 25/06/2010 10:22:27 AM, on The Herald
the main prejudice in it is the differentiation of the wealthy and the not so wealthy. Average Joe loses the the plot and he's a nutbag, loon, window licker, etc. Wealthy bloke goes off the rails and he's "eccentric" or "colourful". I reckon we're all nutbags from time to time, it's just a matter of degrees.
Posted by fista, 25/06/2010 10:52:28 AM, on The Herald
Well said, leahkf. I think it is the behaviours and decisions that people exhibit, rather than the raw IQ status, that people pick on. I know many truly wonderful, exciting, worthy people who are not what society (I) would call super intelligent. One is a teacher and an incredible artisit. I wish I had that sort of artisitc gift. I don't. Another is a self made personal coach, who inspires and engourages people everywhere. What a skill! One bloke I know, who is a keen punter, can somehow calcualte the various payoff permutations of bets that involve rolling one result into another, into another, etc. That's bloody hard, but he does it on the trot, in real time, after a dozen schooners. And he's a labourer. These people aren't nutters or 'dumb'. They ain't brain surgeons (nor am I), but they lead valuable, worthwhile, purposeful, interesting lives. They make good life decisions, and behave rationally and sanely. On the other hand, I know some people with incredible raw IQ scores. These people are, by IQ score, genii. Their erratic behaviour, incomprehensible decision making, and bizarre mental processes, however, lead me to describe them as nutters. Most are medical specialists. Hmm
Posted by Abundance, 25/06/2010 10:58:48 AM, on The Herald
This is all a bit 'PC', is it not? In society, there are nutcases. Crazy people, from the slightly deranged, the eccentric, to the fully gone lunatic like Martin Bryant. There are also hopeless idiots, who ricochet from idiotic decision to idiotic decision, and don't do a lot of good. The wonderful thing about a wealthy society that respects the general rule of law is that we can accommodate all types. I'm happy to pay my taxes, if it means the nutters and the idiots can be looked after and have a decent life, with security and freedom. I hope that doesn't sound arrogant or patronising, becasue it is intended to be honest and respectful. None of us can do everything. Those who can contribute to the economic prosperity of the community should make sure that those people who contribute in other ways are looked after. I enjoy other people's cooking, art, music, company. I respect their contribution to our society. How boring would the place be if everyone was like me?? Insufferably boring is the answer. I believe that it is only honest to acknowledge that there are different levels of ability, IQ, capability. Unfortunately, we do tend to value only a narrow spectrum of the rainbow.
Posted by Abundance, 25/06/2010 11:13:18 AM, on The Herald
Me PC? Give it a break Abundance!
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 25/06/2010 12:49:24 PM
When I see a nutter...I think "eccentric" - and I like eccentrics.
Posted by stevo106, 25/06/2010 11:52:14 AM, on The Herald
So do I Stevo. True eccentrics, rather than confected eccentrics, see themselves as normal and everyone else as eccentric.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 25/06/2010 12:05:34 PM
As you said Jeff, the redheads are rising but if Julia gets cranky or upset, should it be known as Prime Ministerial Ranga Anger?
Posted by MizJasper, 25/06/2010 12:02:20 PM, on The Herald
An interesting topic today. There are a myriad manifestations of mental illness, and the labels placed upon such people in my view tends to be a function of there interactions and relations with other people. Many people simply go unnoticed, and therefore unlabelled. Those with frank delusions, odd beliefs and violent or unusual behaviour towards others are those that invariably wear the label “nutter” or “psycho” particularly if they are financially disadvantaged. The financially secure are often viewed somewhat more kindly, particularly if they are able to contribute meaningfully to society in other ways. Of course willingness to adhere to therapy (and obviously its effectiveness) can make a huge difference in how a mentally ill person is perceived by the community, particularly if they can control the more alarming aspects of their behaviour. I’m quite happy to put my hand up and say I have used those terms. The mentally ill as a group within society has its fair share of arseholes. So are some people with heart disease or cancer.
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 25/06/2010 1:27:14 PM, on The Herald
I have two interesting encounters in recent months with people who display strong signs of being mentally ill. Well, without giving too much away it is clear that their behaviour has moved from mere eccentricity to illness. In the first encounter I greeted a mentally ill fellow I see fairly often, he responded and what ensued was an unexpectedly intelligent conversation (on his part!). In the second a fellow I've seen acting very strangely in the street many times approached me about something or other I'd written, and it emerged that he is a daily reader of my column who had a much better recall of them than I had. He had something interesting to say on every subject we raised. These fellows' unexpected lucidity reminds me that the mentally ill are not necessarily mentally ill all the time.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 25/06/2010 1:59:27 PM
Relative intelligence is another thing altogether. On a continuum of intelligence there must by definition be those above and below the mean, which is generally accepted as an IQ of 100. This of course does take into consideration social or emotional intelligence. One can be quite intelligent from an IQ perspective, but also an “idiot”. In this context an “idiot” is not the clinical manifestation of “idiocy”. I quite like this definition of an idiot –someone who acts in a self defeating or significantly counter productive way. There are a few regular posters on this blog who I think fit this description rather neatly. They make claims which are demonstrably false or hypocritical. When confronted with evidence to the contrary a rational person would generally withdraw the claim or accept the inconsistencies of there arguments. The “idiot” persists in pursuing false or hypocritical stance, or indulges in obfuscation or dissembling. For individual like this I have no hesitation in applying the term idiot.
Posted by Directeur Sportif, 25/06/2010 1:28:09 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...