Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 No myna problem 

No myna problem

Since 2007 Clarence Valley Council has provided the material to a Work for the Dole group to make traps for the Indian or common myna and today it has 90 such traps keeping the population of this winged rat in check throughout the beautiful Clarence. The materials cost of each trap is $17 and they are lent free to any resident who offers to set and check them. The birds, about 2500 since trapping began early last year, are killed with carbon dioxide if and when they're delivered to the council's depots at Grafton and Maclean. Many more are killed by the trappers, humanely of course, to save themselves the trip.

I became aware of the Grafton council's trapping program when it was mentioned in a letter to The Herald a week ago, and subsequently a letter writer who has one of the council's traps told how he'd been able to keep myna numbers down in his immediate area at Wooli. That fellow, Bruce Leyshon, caught seven mynas in 2006, 16 in 2007 and 45 last year, and while that suggests that the myna population at his Wooli home is increasing, the reality is that he's getting better at the trapping. The trick is, Mr Leyshon tells me, to set the trap and to bait it with pet food before dawn and to remove (and dispose of) the trapped mynas after dark. Oh, and to keep a couple of myna birds as call birds.

That's where I went wrong with my trap, which I made myself (Google "pee gee's myna trap") and which has caught only one myna. The problem is that a myna-hating friend became so excited on seeing the trapped myna that he immediately took it from the trap as a couple of dozen sqawking mynas watched and, as Mr Leyshon puts it, dislocated its neck. Since that moment of frenzy not a single myna has expressed an interest in the pet food in the trap.

There are all manner of questions here. Does protecting native birdlife from the murderous myna justify an open season on the bird? Are we not at risk of being in the same field, figuratively, as the shooters who want to sate their blood lust in our national parks? And should councils in the Hunter take up the Clarence Valley traps program?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The comparism with hunting is valid and true. I have put up nesting boxes for rosellas and know that the greatest threat to the rosie's are indian myna's. In a world of diminishing biodiversity and unable to stem the downfall we should at a minimum remove the alien accelerants that we can . Indian mynas,foxs, rabbits etc. in a socially acceptable way of course. Unfortunatley we do to little about alieviating the impact of the planets greatest predator -ourselves.
Posted by squarck, 18/08/2009 10:47:36 AM, on The Herald
So Jeff, what are your thoughts on shooters with an Elmur Fudd complex taking down Mynas in national parks? And when do I get to hunt animals wearing white-rimmed sunglasses and driving ricebox cars?
Posted by Scott Hillard, 18/08/2009 11:33:46 AM, on The Herald
Hello Scott. On shooters in national parks my thoughts have been more than clear! A difference between those who trap mynas and those who seek to shoot in national parks is motivation, one being conservation the other fun.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/08/2009 12:18:11 PM
Hi Jeff, i have been trapping and gassing these pesky critters in Wallsend for quite a while using a homemade trap made out of an obsolete duck pen. The less of them the merrier i say.
Posted by Minnie Mynah, 18/08/2009 11:57:52 AM, on The Herald
How many have you caught, Minnie? And how does your trap work?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/08/2009 12:55:29 PM
Scott, you said And when do I get to hunt animals wearing white-rimmed sunglasses and driving ricebox cars? Scott, unless your a gang banger in Lakemba, carrying out a drive by, i doubt that will ever happen for you. :)
Posted by Nafe, 18/08/2009 12:08:12 PM, on The Herald
Is the motivation at all relevant when the end result - a dead animal - is the same?
Posted by Scott Hillard, 18/08/2009 12:41:09 PM, on The Herald
Jeff, I would like to share some observations of the major Myna problem you have discussed. We used to have Mynas at our place; we had other birds like King Parrots, Scaly Breasted, and Musk and Rainbow lorikeets as frequent visitors. Thankfully most of the Mynas have gone but sadly so have the others. The reason for their departure, I believe is the appearance in large numbers of the aggressive native Noisy Miner. I have observed the Noisy Miner chasing every other bird that comes near our house. I have been attacked by gangs of noisy miners myself and I have seen them attack and kill two other birds. They are bastards of the bush. Is the Miner population increasing because of its compatibility with our urban landscape and therefore presenting its own problems? I have known people to mistake native miner and the imported myna. I am not suggesting the Myna is not a pest, or that there is some xenophobic conspiracy orchestrated by those to satisfy their avid bloodlust, but are we sending the right bird to the gas chamber, because of race? How can those people who have cats be so opposed to the Myna?
Posted by Tony Emanuel, 18/08/2009 1:10:14 PM, on The Herald
Agreed Tony, the noisy miner is very aggressive, although unrelated to the common myna. It does seem to have done well in urbanisation, as has the magpie and the currawong. The currawong probably inflicts more damage on the numbers of small birds in urban areas than any other native bird, although I doubt that its impact comes close to that of the introduced myna.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/08/2009 2:50:06 PM
whats the equivalent term for a sociopath when the target is feral animals and not people? Governments (societies)have traditionally emptied jails of criminals to put in the front line of wars (expendable). The comparism being that the most economical to do vermin culling are those who are motivated to do it at their own expense. ( crims for controlled freedom) Governance is another issue -their motivation to do a nasty job is a questionable thing for governace to control unless it breaks the rules or someone or thing gets hurt that should not have. So is imposing ones personal values on someone else serving a lawfull purpose because we dont like why they do it a correct thing to do? The thought of a elephant hunter enjoying his sport chills me to the spine -just as that of a whale harpooner does. But a sharpshooter playing commando taking out feral animals and enjoying playing the role sounds a sensible type cast for the role to me. A shockjock jorno who enjoys offending people for his ratings may be in the same category as 'elmor fudd" - taking money or enjoyment at the expense of offending or arousing people values systems. The enjoyment police are at it now?
Posted by squark, 18/08/2009 1:12:10 PM, on The Herald
I had a big prob with the Myna birds resting and pooing all over my balcony. I tried everything I could think of or was told. All to no avail...until one day, after cleaning up the poo and re-painting the rails I hung a few feather dusters. It did the trick, no more Mynas’. Took the dusters down after about one month and the birds have not come back in near a year, until last week I saw some poo !! maybe the Mynas? So up went the duster again for a while. I may have sent my prob somewhere else, but....
Posted by Gary H in Singo, 18/08/2009 1:31:03 PM, on The Herald
Great idea, Gary! What colour was the duster?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/08/2009 2:50:33 PM
dont tell him gary -he will take it out and show it where he gets his free beers.
Posted by ex-mate, 18/08/2009 4:17:57 PM, on The Herald
No no, ex, I have a feather boa for that.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/08/2009 4:28:14 PM
Last year I went on a big game shoot with Bobert Rorsak in Zimbabwe to down a Myna bird. It cost me $100,000.00 to shoot the great beast and when I put both barrels through the mammoth 400 gram bird I collapsed and sobbed in the ecstacy of the kill. We shared the kill with the local villagers and shooting them in this manner keeps over population down and gives much needed funding to the local villagers.
Posted by Latina Fresh, 18/08/2009 5:10:13 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...