Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Restaurant complaints 

Restaurant complaints

I used to complain about a lousy restaurant meal, and I suppose I've done so dozens of times over three decades. I'd either ask for a replacement or I'd refuse to pay for that particular dish or I'd leave, and I think I always did that quietly and in a measured way. I was not, though, an habitual whinger.

These days, as I write in my column today, I've changed. I am unlikely to protest even under severe provocation, although I hope that's not put to the test again any time soon! Two recent poor experiences at Lower Hunter restaurants had me displaying my new-found passivity. One was a terrible meal from an expensive, fine-dining restaurant capable, I'm sure, of exceptional food, the other lousy entrees and mains from a restaurant that was, I think, working to its usual standard.

It was my wife who, uncharacteristically, complained at the first restaurant, and when I was asked by the restaurateur I gave my account too. At the second the four of us considered cancelling our mains order when the entrees arrived, but we filled our glasses and got on with a good time. Yes, we should have cancelled the mains.

I'm not at all sure that my new reluctance to complain is the best course. I am, believe it or not, averse to conflict, at least when I'm trying to enjoy myself, and so at-the-table protest is extremely unlikely. As well, I can't see the point of the fuss and bother.

The Herald's food writer, Jenny Tarran, suggests sorting out serious complaints at payment time rather than sending a meal back for a replacement, and it is interesting that Jenny shares the relatively new concern about what goes on behind the swinging kitchen doors.

I'm inclined now to pay ne'er to return but I suspect there's a better policy that is fairer to the diner and to the many restaurateurs who strive for a positive experience all round. Each non-returning diner is a fail mark for the restaurateur, and word of mouth is more likely to be devastating for restaurants than most other businesses.

What's your response to lousy restaurant meal?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I am also in the hardily ever complain camp - I always think the best thing you can do for a good restaurant is return and tell all your friends about it. If the food is rubbish, never return and tell all your friends about it! These days, with internet, blogs, twitter, facebook and all sorts of reviews reviews all over the place, restaurants, hotels and other businesses need to ensure they are performing to standard, otherwise everyone soon learns about it!
Posted by King Idiot, 29/05/2009 9:58:27 AM
being in the industry i find myself very picky when dining out one on price and quality,and i also find at times there is no point saying anything when i have a problem with the food because most times the staff don`t care, but if you can find someone who seems to be in charge say something the problem can`t be fixed if the owner or manager dont know there is a problem.one thing i will not accept is a replacement meal who knows what has been done to it in the kitchen, have never done this myself but have heard plenty of stories from chefs that have and it makes me sick that people could do it.also just becuase your paying top dollar doesn`t mean you are getting a good meal or service,I pride myself on my service and the food we serve and the comments i get from customers if you look after your customers your looking after your business, alot of eatery`s in newcastle need to pick there act up on service there quaility of food and also there prices and stop ripping the public off with what they are serving
Posted by Robyn, 29/05/2009 10:00:23 AM
i went to a restaurant in the junction last week and it was so dark you could hardly read the menu and when the food arrived you could not see what was on the plate. this bothered me because i wondered what i was actually eating. I tell you Amigo, i will never go back there again. with a qualified chef (no longer working in the industry) as a son i have heard some dreadful stories that make me reluctant to eat out anymore. i think the only food you can trust is maccas.
Posted by senior sergeant smith, 29/05/2009 10:36:21 AM
I usually walk after dinner & tell them I will never return until new ownership if it is crap. If you watch the A Current Affairs on NBN television at 7.00pm tonight it will be telling us the site that can tell everyone who has the penalties about the health & inproper food regulations act & has every restaurant name that has the fines issued for 12 months & what they got the penalties issued for. When these sort of places are fined for inproper regulations they have to go on a 12 months inspection bond that any public person is allowed to view on a website that will be named tonight on A Current Affair at 7.00pm. Worth the look !!
Posted by Tough Titties, 29/05/2009 12:08:32 PM
Surely, Tough Titties, you don't eat and not pay?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/05/2009 12:48:49 PM
I eat out very regularly in restaurants, and fortunatley, seem to get a low number of dud meals. I have had a few, and do live in fear of what goes on behind closed doors if I complain. I reckon the most effective strategy (be prepared to go hungry) is to ask for the manager AND the chef/cook ~ together, at your table; explain the problem before you have eaten much of the dish; tell them what you want done (replacement or refund, etc). Personally, I'm more of the 'get up and leave' type, but only after I have done the above. Most restaurant owners are very aware of the power of word of mouth, and will endeavour to remedy. But beware the vengenful cook.................
Posted by Abundance, 29/05/2009 12:16:01 PM
My son is a chef and I have work experience in some restaurants in Newcastle. There is one habit chefs have that appears to be universal. I have discussed this with my son and he said all the chefs do it Testing flavour. Dipping their index finger in a sauce pot, and slurping the food into their mouth and returning their finger to the pot to repeat the dose. with a swirling motion. I have personally witnessed this many many times. Hmmmmmmmm.... Yummy in your tummy. Enjoy!
Posted by old boy, 29/05/2009 1:00:07 PM
Isn't it just about taking the good with the bad? I dread going out with a group of people sometimes as there's always someone who seems to want to find something to complain about. I've had some horrible moments in restuarants - real Fawlty Towers moment - yet it's been worth it as it's now really funny and makes you appreciate the other times more. Simple - if you didn't get the service/food/experience you wanted, just right it off and don't go again....and tell others of course
Posted by stevo, 29/05/2009 1:03:24 PM
That's my inclination these days, Stevo. Lousy restaurants help us appreciate the good ones.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 29/05/2009 1:06:43 PM
senior sargent smith, you taste explains every thing.
Posted by grogadigger, 29/05/2009 1:14:05 PM
senior sergeant smith will have to reprimand his snouts. "Maccas" eight mentions on the food authority site. Get um in line Sarge. Mac rat with the works.
Posted by old boy, 29/05/2009 1:42:20 PM
Tough Titties you can view the info at: www.foodauthority.nsw.gov.au/pena lty-notices As a hungry man, I rarely complain about the food, I only complain when I get the wrong order. Some years back we ordered a Vegetarian Pizza from a place long since closed. When we got home we found our vegetarian pizza covered in prawns, so we took it back and politely advised the owner. He attempted to convince us, that a prawn is a vegetable (without success) then he absolutely lost it !!! and began screaming and yelling and came out from behind the counter swinging, that's when I grabbed him. It was only my wife's intervention that prevented me from inserting a prawn up the backside of an irate pizza shop owner. The shop owner's wife apologized and stated that her husband just can't stand being told. It wasn't the food but the attitude of the Pizzeria owner that left a bad taste in my mouth.
Posted by Colin O., 29/05/2009 3:12:25 PM
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles

Scholarships
 
Kloster No 1. Car Sale
 
Travelworld_See the World
 
EAO_The Loop
 
Hamilton St Patricks Day
 
 
School Newspaper Competition
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...