Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 The embarrassment of Abos 

The embarrassment of Abos

We don't know much of AFL legend Mal Brown in NSW, since that sport is more or less confined to the lower levels of Australia, but we do know where Mr Brown was coming from when he referred to Aboriginal AFL players as cannibals and Abos. At an AFL lunch on Wednesday Mr Brown made a forgettable joke about bad lighting being responsible for a failure to pick Aboriginal players in an AFL Origin team, referring to those players as cannibals, and he exacerbated the difficulties when he warned newspaper reporters as he left not to write "what I said about those Abos"!

We know that Mr Brown was coming straight out of a bygone era when Abos were a shade or two less than white Australians, and hence our national embarrassment. In my column in The Herald today I describe how in my experience in country NSW towns the term Abo was used to describe Aboriginal people who lived in garbage-strewn, fly-saturated camps just beyond the town limits, not Aboriginal people who lived and worked in town. We saw these people of the camps as having lower standards than we did, and they did, and so we thought less of them. We thought even less of the white people with them because these white people did not have the excuse of aboriginality!

Slowly we came to see that we could and should do more to help these people of "the blacks camp" rise from the hopelessness that seemed to crush them, and we have. While Mr Brown's boorish terms discredit him and embarrass us, no harm is done in reminding us of those times.

But how does his "Abos" differ from Andrew Johns's "black c..."? Andrew Johns used the term in urging Blues players to carefully mark the Maroons' Greg Inglis, and on Wednesday night we saw that they should have paid more attention. In the context of its use the term was one of respect, even admiration.

Do you see the difference I see?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I guess I see the difference you're hinting at Jeff, part of me though thinks that we in the hunter are making excuses for Joey simply because he is Knight royalty. While he was definatley acknowledging that Inglis is a skilled player and was to be respected on the field, his use of the term "black c..." to describe him did not show respect for him. Mal Brown merely showed the attitudes of many in the west of Australia toward our Indigenous brothers, go to Perth and be shocked to see just how much those attitudes you described regarding "Abo's" in the 60's and 70's here, remain firm in the west. You would be shocked to hear what comes out of thier mouths regarding Aboriginals. Brown's comments and Joey's are very unfortunate and should be discussed as much as they are...good peice Jeff.
Posted by Bradko, 18/06/2010 7:32:25 AM, on The Herald
I'm with you on this one Jeff. As I grew up one of the best player of rugby league in Newcastle in the 1970's that I Idolised was a Koori man by the Name of John "Choco" Anderson, this man during this time took no offence of the nickname and every child Idolised this man to which he became one of the Newcastle Rugby League bosses. What I've seen over the years is one koori fella calling his best mate a black barstard, what I'll ask you Jeff, is that racist? Is calling a white person a Gu-ba racist? I have friends from all walks of life around this world and cop it off all of them now and again & give it back just as hard, I'm not racist either. There is a difference to racism and mucking around with friends. One thing I can say Jeff is that it is not all one sided with racisl abuse remarks and you just have to got to koori knockout to work that out real quick... Everyone has stuffed up with remarks about a persons colour in life.. Red , White, Yellow, Green or Black, but one thing we have never seen a complaint about is a white person whinging that someone has called them a white c---. I use to live with a fijian that use to call me a white bastard. Is that racist?
Posted by Storm Boy, 18/06/2010 9:34:57 AM, on The Herald
And here is a poem that we all should listen to no matter where we all come from: Sticks And Stones Will Break Our Bones, But Names Will Never Hurt Us ! Pity this is a childrens poem that we are taught and teach our own children , no matter what colour we are. Has Timana ever made a racist remark in his lifetime? If he says no, he is lying to himself, anyone that says they never have are kidding themselves too .
Posted by Storm Boy, 18/06/2010 9:48:00 AM, on The Herald
Choc Anderson introduces himself as Choc Anderson. We could see that as a statement that he feels no shame in being Aboriginal, just as I have no shame about being red headed, but I think we'd be reading too much into it. I don't think Choc Anderson needs to make any such statement.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/06/2010 10:05:37 AM
I use the term Abo myself, just like i use the term Stevo, Jono, Richo, Watto, etc etc, Its a shortening of the name etc etc. I don't need to elaborate more. IN the past i'm sure there were pleanty of names that are used as a degrogitory term against our Abo friends, I don't use the term as a derogitory term, but more as a discriptive term. for eg, If you were at a party with all Aboriginals, and 1 white fella, then if someone asks you, where's nafe, naturally you'd say, he's the white fella over there. But if it was totally opposite, and someone came to me and said Where Ernie Dingo, i's naturally say He's the abo bloke (or maybe i would say he's the black fella over there.) either way, its used as discriptive and not as a derogitory term. The AFL bloke, calling them cannibals is way over the line, but i don't really see what Joey said what too bad due to a) no mallice in being racist and b) used as an adjuective, i bet if he was talking about Fui Fui Moi Moi or simil ilk, he'd call him a fat c... Maybe i am out of touch in this PC world but this is exactly what i think.
Posted by Nafe, 18/06/2010 9:53:43 AM, on The Herald
I see it as an ugly word, nafe, and I always have.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 18/06/2010 10:10:01 AM
Jeff, I'm a tad confused after your comments yesterday regarding Aboriginal people living away from main stream, and your colume today. Yesterday you stated they were disadvantaged and today they are seen as second class citizens. Are you saying that was years ago but today they are not seen in that light? I would also like to say I have enjoyed many of the regular bloggers, C@O, SSS, Leafk, SH and more for their true values shinning through, but having been away for some time and contributing to a blog yesterday only to be abused twice for no purpose it seems to me that you can change the stance of some people or make them reflect, but others have no change and only spite. I wish you all the best my circumstances are now taking me in a more adventureous direction. And C&O give yourself and family some praise, you's have endured and hopefully finding peace.
Posted by Buell, 18/06/2010 10:01:33 AM, on The Herald
Most of personality and physical attributes is genetic. Let's not pretend that all races are the same. You can value different attributes so that you can make all creatures equal, but the word equal does not mean "the same".
Posted by Dennis, 18/06/2010 10:05:49 AM, on The Herald
Jeff, Sorry if you find that offensive, I will ensure not to use it on your blog. I think most perceived racist remarks are not said with the intention of being racist or with the intent to be hurtful and derogitory to another's race or ancestory or heritage or to try and claim superiority over them, but out of ignorance. I know i probably fall into this category all the time. I say things and the race of the person doesn't even cross my mind. EG, that apparent racest KFC ad where the Aussie was sitting with West Indian supporters and was intimidated so shared his chicken. the race didn't even cross my mind, even to the point of pointing somone out and saying he's the black fella over there, etc. I know what i am trying to say here, but not sure if its coming accross properly.
Posted by Nafe, 18/06/2010 10:21:51 AM, on The Herald
Bradko - Royalty or Court Jester?
Posted by Gen X, 18/06/2010 10:22:19 AM, on The Herald
Andrew Johns' use of the 'c' word is not the issue. That term is used widely, in almost every context. It's still a shocker, though. Without trying to defend him, in context, Johns' choice of words was understandable. Regrettable, clumsy, but understandable. He was certainly acknowledging (with implicit respect) Inglis's professional prowess. In a way, Brown's use of 'Abos' is a more derogatory and demeaning term. It is a deeply dismissive, painfully disrespectful term, and disappointingly retrograde, when you think about the real progress being made in helping disadvantaged Indigenous Australian people. How would Mal Brown feel if he was publicly vilified as a 'dickhead bogan wanker', something any Aussie male would hate to be labelled? Should Joey have used more acceptable words? Of course. How likely was he to have chosen better words? Not very. Should Tahu man up a bit, after all these years? probably. Personally, I reckon rugby league is one setting in which indigenous people are pretty well represented, and can achieve, earn, succeed with well deserved equality.
Posted by Abundance, 18/06/2010 10:22:24 AM, on The Herald
Dennis, you have hit the nail on the head, People need to stop looking to be offended and if you are being discribes as a black so and so, or a white so and so, or a yellow so and so, its discriptive, its nothing about your race, its your appearance. Like being called a 4 eyed so and so, or a fat so and so, or a read headed so and so.
Posted by Nafe, 18/06/2010 10:24:49 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...