Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Youth versus experience 

Youth versus experience

I couldn't count the number of men who've contacted me over the past 15 years to discuss discrimination against older job applicants. I've written about the experiences of quite a few of these men, and for all of them the unremitting rejection of their applications for a job in their longtime industry has been soul destroying. They all had extensive experience and knowledge and an eagerness to work but none could get to the short list. Usually their application was not even acknowledged. The problem was that age - and these men were as young as 40 - was seen as old fashioned, and it may be, too, that employers were inclined to see mature men as winding down to retirement and resistant to change. Women of mature age didn't seem to suffer this age discrimination, at least not in some industries.

Well, a government-funded and extensive survey by Monash University has found that after decades of discrimination against mature workers employers are, suddenly, putting people of senior years at the top of the recruiting list. According to the survey of 600 major organisations, 50 per cent of public service organisations and 40 per cent of private employers prefer now to employ people over age 55. Research leader Professor Philip Taylor describes this as a significant and surprising shift and the first time in his 19 years of studying employer attitudes that he's seen such a willingness to employ seniors.

What's going on? Is it that employers are recognising that experience is more important than beauty? That the increasing number of mature Australians prefer to deal with mature people in matters of consequence?

Perhaps. But I believe we are emerging from the age of youth, an age at least three decades long and one that seems to have matched the rise of television as an entertainment media. It may be that the increasing population of mature Australians is forcing an acceptance that age is not ugly or even undesirable. It may be also just part of the cycle of attitudes that seems always to have Australians swinging from one extreme to the other. I hope we don't come to spurn young people!

Have you or someone you know been a victim of age discrimination? Do you agree that we may be emerging from the age of youth?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I personally have found that being a mature female, has distinct disadvantages in job seeking. I get the impression that younger employers, are scared of our wealth of knowledge and experience, instead of embracing it and taking advantage of that asset. I would much rather pass on all my skills than have them lost in time, by someone who has not got the sense to realise what is before their eyes. I don't ever strive to take over my employers role, but I feel very satisfied to be able to help grow the business I am employed in, by introducing past experience to encourage growth. If the employer lacks the business sense to see potential, then perhaps they will never move a company forward.
Posted by Rose- Lake Macquarie, 26/08/2010 8:52:52 AM, on The Herald
Making the best fist of the job you're employed to do is what it's about, Rose. Mature women seem to take a special quality to a workplace, and I think employers recognise that. Still, I am sure there are many instances of skilled women not getting the job because of their age.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 26/08/2010 9:56:58 AM
it's probably because every second job applicant has a heap of tattoos and some metal hanging out their face. ask a person with tattoos and piercings who they would want to have represent them in court: they have a choice of two identical twin solicitors wearing the same clothes, only difference is one has tattoos and piercings while the other does not. i know the answer..... i also think that "older" people are not as old as they used to be.... they live longer, tend to eat better and be healthier. they have also had their kids and are keen to get back into the swing of regular work. they also don't go out much during the week and come to work hungover and tired. they are also wiser. they would also be less inclined to shop around for jobs and therefore be a stable employee. lots of advantages in employing them.
Posted by judgedredd, 26/08/2010 9:36:53 AM, on The Herald
Two good points, judge. The first is interesting, and right or wrong, good or bad, the fact is that tattooed young people will be denied many jobs because of the tatts. Frankly, I think they have no-one to blame but themselves.
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 26/08/2010 9:58:39 AM
I interviewed a large number of final applicants many years ago and at the end of it was left shaking my head in disbelief. Apart from the usual untidy, nose piercings, tattoos, etc.. the thing that amazed me was the lack of basic maths and grammar skills even though they had their HSC. The position would have been very suited to a mature lady but none applied and they would have had no trouble in beating the competition. Do not despair, mature employees are very valued and sought after, and not just for their knowlege and experience but their ethics & principles.
Posted by Barney, 26/08/2010 10:30:54 AM, on The Herald
All the youngsters are saving themselves the trouble of inteviews now as one can check them out being stupid on facebook and youtube?
Posted by facebook, 26/08/2010 10:56:35 AM, on The Herald
Young people are often terribly narcissistic. Generation Y is said to be particularly afflicted by this selfish blight. It means that they cannot see the world beyond their own interest. They will only do things which give them personal gratification, or narcissistic supply. This means that they will not follow instructions, which is a disability which makes them almost unemployable. Perhaps they will grow out of it with a bit of life experience, but right now it is better to employ a more mature worker.
Posted by Jenny, 26/08/2010 11:52:23 AM, on The Herald
Having reached the pinnacle in several of my former positions, I have in the past applied for somewhat lesser roles only to be inerviewed by far younger, less experienced and less qualified than I was only to see the blank look come over their faces . It was either they felt inferior or were not interested in case I took their role, a role I might add I did not want. I had had my share of management and no longer wanted that stress.
Posted by MizJasper, 26/08/2010 11:56:12 AM, on The Herald
Age (experienced) V youth, or visa versa. No contest here. "Youth wins out every time." An intelligent youth is far more an attractive job proposition. This apparent shift to oldies (experienced) is a false stat. All the top jobs go to the best. There is no way an oldie can compete with the best young applicants. All young people are not drongos.
Posted by old boy, 26/08/2010 11:57:39 AM, on The Herald
I'm pushing 30, but apparently I'm already too old for casual work, unless it's during a weekday, which oddly enough is when I work in a full time capacity. Also, I'm in an odd position in my industry, where I'm too old for a junior or mid level role, but not old enough for a senior role.
Posted by Direct, 26/08/2010 12:16:25 PM, on The Herald
At a certain age you become too old to be a Toy boy and too Young to be a Sugar daddy. What is happening now is connected to a skill shortage, when things die down in the mining industry the young guns will be snapped up leaving the oldies grumbling again. Think about it, are you going to hire a guy 25 with a mortgage and kids or a 65 yo who wants to retire soon.
Posted by deathwarmedup, 26/08/2010 12:37:16 PM, on The Herald
We were in our mid 40's & 9.5 years in our jobs when we were made redundant within a month of each other. Never having dealt with CES before, found it so frustrating that we went out and bought our own small business. That was possible because by our age we had enough security for a loan. This is often the only option for mature age unemployed.
Posted by tina, 26/08/2010 1:01:12 PM, on The Herald
Unfortunately, tina, buying a business with the golden handshake usually spells disaster. The failure rate for BHP workers who bought or created a business with their termination pay was very high. It appears, though, that your business was a goer, and that's good! What sort of business, tina? And are you still in business, employed or retired?
Posted by Jeff Corbett on 26/08/2010 1:08:05 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Bounce
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...