News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 3 earthquakes shake Hunter Region 

3 earthquakes shake Hunter Region

22 Jun, 2010 04:00 AM
Camberwell has been shaken by three earth tremors within 24 hours, the latest in a series of quakes to hit the Hunter Region.

The minor earthquakes, which struck on Sunday, were recorded at a seismograph station more than 75 kilometres from the mining village.

The strongest, measuring 2.2 on the Richter scale, struck about 8.45pm.

It shook houses in the village, waking residents.

"I was nearly thrown out of bed," resident Deidre Olofsson said.

"It was absolutely frightening, I have never been so scared."

The tremors add to another 51 Hunter earthquakes in the past 20 years, prompting questions over whether they are linked to the region's booming mining industry.

With magnitudes up to 5.3, the quakes were recorded at Geoscience Australia, a government agency in Canberra.

A map plotting their locations show the vast majority of tremors occurred in the heart of the Hunter's mining country near Cessnock, Muswellbrook and Dungog.

The largest was at Ellalong on August 6, 1994, which was the biggest quake in the region since Newcastle's 1989 earthquake.

John Polglase, a geologist from Bundella, west of Murrurundi, said mining-induced seismic activity had been well documented worldwide, and blasting or a longwall mining method called "top caving" could be associated with Hunter quakes.

"Nature has flaws and compressed and folded strata have weaknesses. If you do any blasting or mining you can activate those flaws and cause local movements of rock," he said.

"Some of the earthquakes could be due to blasting, and some can be due to faults and fractures and fissures shifting due to loading or unloading of the strata. You can even get rock readjustment from large coal train movements."

Mr Polglase said the "cluster of middle-order shocks" in the Hunter indicated a need to investigate the tremors and confirm their cause.

"A longwall mining collapse or quarry explosions can be quite measurable," he said.

But the NSW Minerals Council has ruled out a study to investigate the supposed link between the Hunter's mining industry and earthquakes.

"This issue was raised in 2007 and the experts ruled out a link between mining and seismic activity then," a NSW Minerals Council spokesman said.

Geoscience Australia seismologist David Jepsen said there was no evidence to prove or disprove earthquakes were linked to mining.

Mr Polglase said conflicting theories would remain until seismometers were strategically placed in the region to deliver more accurate data about seismic activity.

"Until we get independent observers using the right equipment in the right locations we cannot make dogmatic statements," he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Earthquakes in the Hunter near Cessnock, Muswellbrook and Dungog eh! Sorry to knock Mr Polglase bu all these areas are geologically well known. Dungog is "basement" rock known to locals for earthquakes. Cessnock region and Muswellbrook have known geological structures responsible for earthquakes. Certain types of mining do cause very small scale earthquakes. Rarely if ever get beyond around 2.0. Ask an expert inmine seismicity such as Dr P. Mikula in Kalgoorlie. Longwall mining for coal causes ground vibration but hardly at earthquake level. Ellalong area is well known for this as was Teralba. So lets get the facts correct before blaming mining outright. Just remember that comment about Dungog. No records for the area, only local knowledge. great place to build a dam?
Posted by Harold, 22/06/2010 7:09:50 AM, on The Herald
are the tremors are linked to mining? i would bet there is something there..... an independent study, financed by the mines, NOW, please.
Posted by judgedredd, 22/06/2010 8:15:11 AM, on The Herald
You simply can not relocate and remove major volumes of the regions earth surface without having an impact. Take some rivets out of theharbour bridge and see what happens!
Posted by Bigfeller, 22/06/2010 8:28:22 AM, on The Herald
Possible causes might also include reservoir -induced seismicity. It does happen -several shakes in the southern highlands have been due to loading -unloading of strata in the vicinty of water storages. Interested persons could also look up Thompson dam (Vic), Xinfengjiang dam (China), Vaiont dam (Italy), Koyna dam (India) and so on. Perhaps another important reason why Tillegra dam should not be built, especially since pore pressure fields in these strata are not accurately predictable.
Posted by bo, 22/06/2010 8:53:54 AM, on The Herald
Poor Camberwell, now surrounded by diggings and prospective open cuts with Ashton Coal's application to mine south of the township. If these were shallow quakes I would blame earth disturbance. Equally alarming is the possible disappearance of Glennies Creek, the major outlet from Lake St Clair not far from its junction with the Hunter.
Posted by pablo, 22/06/2010 9:06:41 AM, on The Herald
Before everyone gets too excited and blames mining there has been recorded earthquakes in this area since the arrival of European settlers. Up to the 1989 earthquake there was no seismographs in Newcastle so it does not surprise than the number recorded since has increased. A 2.2 recording on the Richter scale is so insignificant most people in a noisy environment and near moving traffic would have probably not noticed it at all.
Posted by cardiffresident, 22/06/2010 9:30:11 AM, on The Herald
It seems the Mineral Council's approach is "Don't look under that rock. We might not like what you find."
Posted by metoo, 22/06/2010 10:54:39 AM, on The Herald
I agree with "cardiffresident". Earthquakes have been occurring in the Hunter region, quite regularly, for over 200 years. There is a wealth of information available about earthquakes since 1868, the year Newcastle was rocked by a particularly destructive quake. The historian Cynthia Hunter has documented most of the events in a book, published in 1988. It seems she missed the opportunity to document the biggest of them all.
Posted by mend6327, 22/06/2010 12:27:06 PM, on The Herald
2.2 and she was nearly thrown out of bed? Ha! Nice one Deidre!
Posted by jimi_jones, 22/06/2010 4:33:02 PM, on The Herald
Safe areas to build & store toxic "coal combustion product placement " ie: ash dams as well?
Posted by well il be damned, 22/06/2010 5:53:46 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles


 
Landcom Sanctuary 190512
 
 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...