News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Camberwell Common case lost 

Camberwell Common case lost

18 Oct, 2011 03:00 AM
CAMBERWELL resident Deidre Olofsson has lost her court challenge to former Lands Minister Tony Kelly’s decision to revoke control of the village common.

Ms Olofsson, represented by the Environmental Defenders Office, challenged the legitimacy of the minister’s removal of the common from the Camberwell Common Trust’s control in April last year.

The 90-hectare common, which had been controlled by a community trust since 1876, was resumed and its control given to Ashton Coal.

A related company, White Mining, lodged a mining lease application on the land in May last year.

The Environmental Defender’s Office initially launched the case on behalf of the Camberwell Common Trust in April.

The court ruled the trust could not be represented as the applicant, which resulted in Ms Olofsson becoming the applicant.

Ms Olofsson argued that the action did not comply with statutory provisions of the Commons Management Act, 1989, and the Crowns Land Act, 1989.

Land and Environment Court Chief Judge Brian Preston dismissed Ms Olofsson’s challenge last week.

‘‘I have concluded that none of the grounds of challenge to the reservation revocation and grant licence have been established and that the proceedings should be dismissed,’’ Justice Preston wrote.

An earlier maximum costs order meant meant that Ms Olofsson would be liable to pay a maximum of $10,000 if she lost the case.

Justice Preston ruled that Ms Olofsson pay $5000 costs to the Crown Solicitor’s Office and $5000 costs to White Mining and Ashton Coal.

Ms Olofsson said she was considering legal advice before deciding whether to appeal.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
What a tragic decision this is.

It represents a loss to the entire nation. We have no rights.

I believe the Legal systems do not represent us.

Posted by Kurri 'n Rose, 18/10/2011 4:03:49 AM, on The Herald
I think this is great news where an unsucessful litigant has been ordered to contribute towards costs. Hopefully it will make future litigants think twice before they instigate legal proceedings.
Posted by thinkitthrough, 18/10/2011 5:26:45 AM, on The Herald
we sell our soul for coal it seems


Posted by marshy, 18/10/2011 5:48:49 AM, on The Herald
In my opinion, it only goes to show that normal people have little say when big business wants to take over.

So will the common be returned when the mine is finished?

Posted by Bigfeller, 18/10/2011 7:38:08 AM, on The Herald
I totally agree with the comments made by thinkitthrough , it's about time some of the people who challenge everything through the courts , generally at the taxpayers expense , were held accountable when they are judged to be in the wrong. I sincerely hope that this ruling may open some eyes.
Posted by smithy, 18/10/2011 8:04:10 AM, on The Herald
We have a member of the community standing up for everyone and the environment. Not only is the finding against her, there are costs awarded!

This is an absolute disgrace. I think it's another nail in the coffin of the Upper Hunter.

Where is the government? Where are you Mr Souris?


Posted by horsetrader, 18/10/2011 8:36:12 AM, on The Herald
Sorry to be the eternal cynic and wake you up from your cosy dream but did you really think you were going to win?


Posted by Occams Razor, 18/10/2011 8:41:58 AM, on The Herald
So why isn't the current government intervening in this appalling consumption of village land? - why? because both sides of politics in NSW think the only thing keeping the state afloat is coal mining (they are probably right - but that doesn't justify it)
Posted by Hands off, 18/10/2011 8:52:23 AM, on The Herald
Thinkitthrough,

People are using the legal system as a last resort as I believe the Mining Act gives unfair and undue preference to mining companies over communities, who also have extensive legal resources that private individuals and communities dont have.


Posted by Rob in Margs, 18/10/2011 9:39:53 AM, on The Herald
How about SOF get on board something that actually matters (like this!) instead of worrying about 12 trees in a Newcastle backstreet.....
Posted by MortonBayPIg, 18/10/2011 9:48:00 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
FIGHTER: Diedre Oloffson in Camberwell Common.
FIGHTER: Diedre Oloffson in Camberwell Common.

Most popular articles


 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...