News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Coal dust warning 

Coal dust warning

30 Oct, 2010 12:00 AM
A SENIOR NSW health official says exposure to coal dust particulates can harm people's health, even if the pollution is within state guidelines.

Community lobby group The Australian Coal Alliance said the comment was a "bombshell that has major implications for the Hunter".

The Northern Sydney Central Coast area director for public health Peter Lewis made the submission to the Department of Planning about a South Korean company's plan for the Wallarah No 2 mine in the Wyong Shire.

"Any increased exposure to particulate pollution is associated with increased adverse health outcomes, even if the levels are below the current guidelines," Dr Lewis wrote.

Dr Lewis said increased particulate exposure could cause deaths, require hospital admission, and make children have more chest colds, night-time coughs and trips to the doctor.

Coal alliance spokesman Mike Campbell slammed the state government for not making the document public.

Mr Campbell said the government must review air pollution limits.

"It is a big step forward from a government official to say 'yes there are problems within the current guidelines'," Mr Campbell said.

Dr Lewis's submission said mines on the scale of the Wallarah 2 plan "must be considered in the context of the whole region, not as a stand-alone development".

Mr Campbell said many Hunter coalmines were similar in size to the Wallarah 2 plan.

He said he asked the department for a copy of Dr Lewis's submission but was told "we don't have a copy here, I'll get back to you".

"I had to get it off the author himself," Mr Campbell said.

A Department of Planning spokesman said that before July 1, 2010, major project submissions were not made public.

But the policy had been changed so submissions made after July 1 would be available on the department's website, he said.

Dr Lewis's submission was made on June 9.

"Issues raised in all submissions, including from the health service, will be carefully considered as part of the department's assessment of the [Wyong mine] proposal," the department spokesman said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Its a pity the poiticians and Mine owners do not have to live in or near Coal dust.
Posted by John the Mayor, 30/10/2010 5:44:41 AM, on The Herald
I confirm that 64% of those living within 3km of an open cut mine in the Gloucester Valley, where there is no power station, believe their health has been damaged by the mining. Those living 3 to 5km away from a mine had about half the number of symptoms but this was still substantially more than those living more than 5km away. Another subgroup studied was of people who lived very close to the railway but 7km from the mine. These results came from a survey of 101 households with domestic rain water tanks. further results about heavy metal levels in the water and soil are pending. I understand the Wallarah 2 mine will be an underground mine but their coal dump will be above ground and will have a cumulative impact with Vales Point power station emissions. We need to be told which poisons are from overburden dust, unwashed coal, coal processing chemicals, blast gases, mining vehicle emissions, train emissions. different houses have exposure to different combinations of these sources and protective measures will vary accordingly. Overseas GE CoalPlus has recently advertised antioxidant and dust suppression processes which deserve examination for possible local application.
Posted by steve robinson, 30/10/2010 7:10:55 AM, on The Herald
and just what fine coal particulates are released from the power stations & ash dams which also have for decades been able to blow all over nearby residential & recreational communities?
Posted by duty of care, 30/10/2010 10:50:09 AM, on The Herald
Finally the truth may be leaking out about the damage being done to thousands of people who live in the footprint of the fine particulate dusts (PM10 and below, especilly PM2.5 and below) emanating for tens of kilometres from open cut coal mines and uncovered coal rail carriages so that city dwellers can waste electricity and shareholders can become rich. What has been occurring in the Upper Hunter Valley post 1989 and particularly post 2002 is a wantonly criminal act placing at risk the health and lives of some hundred thousand Australians. Little wonder preventable premature death from dust related diseases in Muswellbrook LGA is 30% above state averages and the health of that community is rated by authorities as below that pertaining to Willcannia, Walgett and the worst in NSW. Thankyou BIG COAL and your CRIMINALLY CORRUPT NSW Government.
Posted by jayz, 30/10/2010 11:12:08 AM, on The Herald
The RTA is about to commence years of spreading a lethal mix of diesel fumes combined with silica and sulphuric acid rock dust throughout the township of Bulahdelah. Some years ago Hunter area health officials from the Mid North Coast were advised of the fact that, despite the existence of viable (cheaper and safer) alternatives, the RTA had determined on a route location with carcinogenic rock dusts. They were also advised and provided with evidence of the fact that the RTA’s intended route was not the safest for road users. Their response was, in effect, ‘trust the RTA’. Had they had even a smattering of Dr. Lewis’s courage and integrity the RTA could have been forced to divert to a safe route at that time. In regard to: "Issues raised in all submissions, including from the health service, will be carefully considered as part of the department's assessment of the [Wyong mine] proposal," the department [of Planning] spokesman said:- Some examples of the Department of Planning’s assessment methods are at: http://bulahdelahbypass.wordpress.com/3-corruptionflaws-director-general%e2%80%99s-report/
Posted by Adeke Carrakk, 30/10/2010 11:32:46 AM, on The Herald
oh my..... ive been called a doomsayer when it comes to these mines but here is some proof. these mines, these coal wagons, these coal loading facilities are are all stupidly bad for the entire environment.
Posted by judgedredd, 31/10/2010 12:17:15 PM, on The Herald
Diesel particulates are far more common than coal dust. They are everywhere where roads are. Does the "Senior NSW Health Official" want to comment on diesel pm2.5's? Does he or she want to ban diesel engines thereby reducing the ALP's primary vote to single digits? Love the hypocrisy.
Posted by Bruce, 1/11/2010 8:19:25 AM, on The Herald

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles


 
Landcom Sanctuary 190512
 
 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...