News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Marks Point property owner drowning in opinions 

Marks Point property owner drowning in opinions

14 Oct, 2011 03:00 AM
A SELF-FUNDED retiree has been told he cannot develop his land at Marks Point because rising sea levels will inundate his property by 2100.

Lake Macquarie City Council staff have recommended refusing Rob Antill’s plan for four two-level dwellings on a 1300-square-metre site.

A council staff report said the development site would have ‘‘a small area permanently inundated by 2050’’.

‘‘The entire site may be permanently inundated by 2100,’’ it said.

For The Herald's opinion on this issue, click here.

Mr Antill lodged a development application for his plan in July this year, after council staff advised him development was allowable.

‘‘I’m not a climate change sceptic, but I think man is smart enough to do something in the next 100 years to figure this out,’’ Mr Antill said. ‘‘The Dutch live below the sea level and they sorted it out.’’

Mr Antill bought his waterfront property in Haddon Crescent for $1.45million in February 2008, three months before the council released its sea level rise policy.

Since then, waterfront property prices in the area have fallen by 30per cent.

Mr Antill accepts the council must consider sea level rise, but believes the risk of being sued is among their main concerns.

‘‘I think the council has elevated opinion to the status of truth,’’ he said, borrowing a phrase from Save Our Figs spokeswoman Fee Mozeley.

The council approved a subdivision for the site in February this year and originally urged Mr Antill to build 40 units on his block, but he took a conservative approach.

He and his wife intend to keep living in a waterfront heritage-listed house they restored and which adjoins the development site.

‘‘We’re not developers looking to maximise profits,’’ Mr Antill said.

The council was satisfied the plan included raising most floor levels to 2.85 metres, but was concerned rumpus rooms would be only 1.56metres high.

Councillors will vote on the matter on Monday night, where they are expected to reject council staff’s recommendation and support the plan in principle, but defer it for further consideration.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The idea that coastal councils have elavated opinion to the status of truth. Makes an arguement for not putting the opinion on Section 149. Which is supposed to advise the reader of facts related to the property, not opionions! Edward James
Posted by Edward James, 14/10/2011 3:36:56 AM, on The Herald
I believe the release of the May 2008 sea level rise policy was a damning indictment of the current Lake Macquarie City councillors.

Did they consult Greg Combet in the Westlake seat of Charlton, and now a Labor Federal Minister for Climate Change?

Did they inspect the beachfront property his ex-wife purchased when they parachuted into the Hunter, landing in the wrong city?


Posted by Laurie Brewster, 14/10/2011 3:39:36 AM, on The Herald
A policy based on unscientific opinion is not worth the cost in cents of electricity to show it on to a computer screen.

When council officers base decisions on flawed policies, the responsibility remains with the elected councillors.

Your rates and service charges will go up again this year and every year unless you the ratepayers and residents take a stand against poor decision making.

Only 11 months until we can elect a new Lake council.

Posted by Laurie Brewster, 14/10/2011 3:39:50 AM, on The Herald
This has to be the ultimate in climatic stupidity. Why not ban all new buildings in case there is another earthquake?
Posted by JB, 14/10/2011 4:47:53 AM, on The Herald
That's the council for you looking towards the future??? I wonder if their got a return ticket to come back to earth
Posted by Late mail, 14/10/2011 5:26:28 AM, on The Herald
doesnt seem to stop them from approving coal loaders on the river.....
Posted by judgedredd, 14/10/2011 5:56:53 AM, on The Herald
This is exactly what happens when people start carrying on about climate change and the environment. Don't worry Mr Antill, gillards carbon tax will fix it.


Posted by TC, 14/10/2011 6:40:07 AM, on The Herald
Global sea levels have been falling for 18 months - yes, falling: see the official Envisat & Jason satellite datasets. Even the worst case the IPCC only estimates 59 cm rise by 2100, and we're undershooting their *lowest* case (18 cm) by more than half now. Its clear from the photo that Mr Antill will not have a problem in any of his next several lifetimes.
Posted by Bruce of Newcastle, 14/10/2011 7:39:04 AM, on The Herald
Ha, this is so typical of Lake Mac Council! Has anyone read their draft Biodiversity Offset Policy? It is just as ridiculous!

Lake Mac, why don't you try applying some common-sense to your policies and planning decisions? From someone who works in the development industry, I feel bad for the "Mum & Dad" developers who have to put up with this rubbish.

Posted by Flossy, 14/10/2011 7:43:59 AM, on The Herald
What Lake Macquarie Council is effectively doing is reducing the value of water front properties in their LGA. All these properties now become less viable for development - the land value drops- making it harder for council to draw sufficient rates from land owners. I hope the Valuer General and iPart reflect this in their valuations and granting of special rates variations in years to come.
Posted by Less value, 14/10/2011 9:08:36 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
UP IN THE AIR: Rob Antill on his Marks Point property, which he hoped to develop to fund his retirement. –  Picture by Ryan Osland
UP IN THE AIR: Rob Antill on his Marks Point property, which he hoped to develop to fund his retirement. – Picture by Ryan Osland

Most popular articles


 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...