News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 More mining approved for Singleton despite cancer cluster fears 

More mining approved for Singleton despite cancer cluster fears

14 Apr, 2010 04:00 AM
MINING companies have been given approval to extract millions of extra tonnes of coal out of Singleton, raising more concerns over the health risks posed by dust.

NSW Premier Kristina Keneally has ordered an investigation into a potential cancer cluster in Singleton, following reports in The Herald and the ABC's Four Corners that five cases had been detected in families living close together in the area.

In the past year, the NSW Government has approved four expansions of coalmining facilities in the Singleton local government area.

Another eight expansions are awaiting approval under the State Government's controversial Part 3A planning laws, which bypass council approval.

The most recent approval took place just weeks ago, with the Ashton coalmine given the nod for an $8.5 million expansion that would lead to an increase in run-of-mine production from 5.2 million to 5.8 million tonnes a year.

In March last year Hunter Valley Operations complex at Jerry Plains was given approval for additional mining and permission to process up to 16 million tonnes of coal at its HVO-south complex.

Greens upper house MLC Lee Rhiannon said the health study should include the entire Hunter.

"Focusing on just one suspected cancer cluster is akin to a GP examining a person's finger when a person presents complaining of feeling ill," Ms Rhiannon said.

"The danger of the Premier relying on the Singleton cancer cluster study alone is that an inconclusive finding will result because of the small number of people involved."

Minister for the Hunter Jodi McKay said yesterday she had never ruled out a health study for Singleton, but she believed it would be difficult to do a "statistically meaningful" comparative study with other areas because of the size of Singleton.

The NSW Minerals Council said yesterday that it took concerns about the potential health effects of mining seriously, but that pinpointing the source of the cancers could be difficult.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
There are thousands of people working in the mining industry in the Hunter, Coal Services do health checks on coal miners including chest xrays, do you not think there would be many more people who are directly associated in the industry in the dust all the time that would have similar medical conditions to people in the cluster group if dust was the primary cause of these cancers. I believe you study should be checking more than dust as this area of the Hunter is also a primary agricultural area with chemicals, pesticides, non-organic foods, peoples lifestyles there are a miriad of things that could potentially cause cancer including genes passed down though families. To just blame mining because it is an easy target is wrong. I have been an u/g miner for 40 yrs, have beaten stomach cancer and 5 generations of my ancestors have been u/g coal miners and have all lived to be 80-90 years old.
Posted by Jimbob, 14/04/2010 7:07:13 AM, on The Herald
The world health organization has a maximum recommended limit for fine dust particles (pm2.5), above which it has been shown that illness will result. Australia has no mandatory pm2.5 standard, and thus these smallest, most dangerous and most mobile of particles are not being tracked after emmission by mines. Who is breathing them in? When the wind blows from the NW, how many of these particles are reaching Newcastle? It seems like nobody wants to look..
Posted by help_u_look, 14/04/2010 7:07:18 AM, on The Herald
Premier Keneally's position is now untenable. She must go. Hang on, why not wait a few months when they will all go.
Posted by Jordo, 14/04/2010 7:20:49 AM, on The Herald
Here we go again. Let's play Pass the Parcel. Only it might be a cancer wrapped inside. 3 main sources of dust. Vehicle movements - inadequate road dust control. Blasting - cannot do anything. Dust still gets into atmosphere whether windy or not. Spoil excavation - no controls effective. Ever seen a dragline stop working on a windy day? Then add the power station fumes. Not visible but sure can smell it. That brown haze constantly over the Hunter Valley is there to stay. Solution? Everybody live in Wollemi National Park!
Posted by Dusted daily, 14/04/2010 7:26:27 AM, on The Herald
research suggests breathing in pollution could trigger brain cancer
Posted by the_link, 14/04/2010 7:42:07 AM, on The Herald
the company gets what the company wants and nothings as precious.... as a hole in the ground.
Posted by judgedredd, 14/04/2010 7:45:49 AM, on The Herald
I don't recall Jodi McKay having any qualifications in medical epidemiology? Since being parachuted into her job she has however often demonstrated an eminent qualification for rejecting the wishes and complaints of the people of Newcastle and the Hunter.
Posted by ColT, 14/04/2010 7:47:12 AM, on The Herald
Jimbob you have beaten me to what I wanted to say, there could well be many things other than the current whipping boy, mining. Unfortunately I did not get to see Four Corners in it's entirity on Monday night however I did not see any miners interviewed. Sad as it is, people do get cancers as well as many other illness, if you survey any community the size of Singleton you will get a similiar result.
Posted by thinkitthrough, 14/04/2010 8:52:25 AM, on The Herald
There is far more dust in Muswellbrook than there is in Singleton. How come it doesnt get a mention???
Posted by The Gaz, 14/04/2010 9:03:39 AM, on The Herald
Well they wouldn't want to upset the "money-machine" would they. Once again complete silence from Barry O'Farrell. What would his Government do in this dilemma? I'd guess exactly the same as the present bunch of useless time-servers! Tweedledee-dee and Tweedledee-dum. The only answer is to elect the Greens!
Posted by anticyclonenic, 14/04/2010 9:12:32 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles


 
 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...