News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Outrage over Loft teen magazine 

Outrage over Loft teen magazine

25/07/2008 10:32:00 PM
A RATEPAYER-financed Newcastle youth magazine has sparked controversy with its latest edition that jokes about self-harm and suicide.

The Loft Youth Venue's InZine publication includes features on where young people can get help for depression and other mental health problems.

But its graphic and provocative editorials, cartoons and word puzzles have sparked outrage with a Newcastle City councillor describing it as "irresponsible".

Cr Helene O'Neill said yesterday community members had raised concerns, which she shared, about the publication.

Two mental health support groups said they would be contacting the Loft to speak to those involved in the magazine's production about its subject matter and presentation.

Newcastle City Council said yesterday the material, which expressed the opinions of the authors only, was intended to address difficult subjects.

Acting general manager Graham Clarke apologised if any reader was offended by the contents.

Some of the most controversial features include a "razor blade cut 'n' play" cartoon clip-out; an "emo find-a-word" with clues such as blood, depressed, noose and razor blade; and a "reason to kill yourself" cartoon series.

Other pages give directions on when "What if I feel like crap?" or helping someone with depression, to contact services such as Kids Help Line and beyondblue.

Cr O'Neill, who works with young athletes as a rugby league development officer, said she believed the magazine sent the wrong message.

"It's the most irresponsible publication when you talk about the high rate of youth suicide," she said.

"If you start putting out books like that when someone perhaps is a little bit confused and they pick up a book like that you're going to have blood on your hands."

Cr O'Neill said she was particularly concerned the magazine was council-endorsed.

"Ratepayers have a right to know where their money is going. If it's going into publications like that you've got to say what better things could we be doing with our monies," she said.

Mr Clarke said an editorial committee of young people and council staff reviewed the content of InZine and would not publish material which they deemed to be offensive.

"The opinions expressed in InZine do not reflect council's opinions or those of any individual other than the authors themselves," Mr Clarke said.

He said one of the purposes of the Loft Youth Venue was to provide an avenue for young people to talk about difficult issues and humour, no matter how dark, could be an icebreaker to addressing these issues.

"However, I apologise if any reader is offended by the contents of the latest edition," he said.

Mr Clarke said the theme for the latest edition was negativity. The next issue, which is scheduled for release in September, is titled Positivity.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Incredible that ratepayers' funds are being squandered like this. Council, stop it immediately! Some time ago, I asked for information on council funding of a gay/lesbian event and received a stream of bureaucratic gobbledegook. It is high time that the council got back strictly to core functions or be replaced by an administrator.
Posted by Mac on 26/07/2008 5:06:15 PM
I do think this approach is not the right approach but I do totally believe more needs to be done to address these issues.
Posted by toali on 28/07/2008 8:40:05 AM
This zine is an outlet for young people. Everyone complains about young people being illiterate or not being interested in the world around them or not engaging in useful activities, and then articles like this attack them when they show an interest in writing, current events and important issues. Nice work. You are never going to support 100% of what your rates are spent on, I know I don't. But The Loft provides kids with somewhere to go, and more importantly, with things to do. Get a sense of humour and leave the kids alone. They're a lot smarter than you give them credit for and will not kill themselves over an emo find-a-word. Good day to you.
Posted by Mel on 30/07/2008 6:25:09 PM
Well then Mac, you should know that it's hard to get funding. Shouldn't you be sympathizing with the Loft rather than writing negative comments towards them?
Posted by 3lla on 31/07/2008 6:23:49 PM
The issue was never meant to be taken seriously. We never were saying things like all emos are depressed. We provided information of where people could go and seek help. I really dont understand what everyone is complaining about.
Posted by -- on 31/07/2008 7:25:20 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
 THE MAGAZINE
THE MAGAZINE
Q: Do you support ratepayer funding of Negativity teen magazine?

It's an appropriate use of ratepayers' money
(56%)

It's an outrageous misuse of ratepayers' money
(44%)

Total Votes: 207
Poll Date: 25 Jul 08

MOST POPULAR

02 Jul 09 | It is very likely we paid most of the cost of installing the household's solar system, and from the beginning of next year we the non-solar public will be paying an extortionate price for the excess product of a solar system we paid for.
Klosters Golf VW
 
 
Top Team
 
 
Newspapers in Education
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...