News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Smart meters blamed for power bill errors 

Smart meters blamed for power bill errors

15 Dec, 2008 08:52 AM
ENERGYAUSTRALIA is being forced to replace thousands of its so-called "smart" meters, because of component failures.

The failures have meant some of the meters cannot be read electronically and householders have complained of unexpectedly high bills based on "estimates" by the power company.

Smart meters record power use according to the time of day, enabling different prices to be charged for peak, shoulder and off-peak periods.

They are designed to encourage reduced power consumption and to spread consumption more evenly throughout the day.

Adams town Heights resident Laurie See said his bill had risen by about 30 per cent since a smart meter was installed several months ago, despite his best efforts to switch power use away from peak periods.

He and wife Rosemary expected their power bill to drop by about 25 per cent.

But when their bill turned up it was about 30 per cent higher than the same period last year and referred to "estimated usage based on all available information".

"I was very disappointed, so rang up to complain," Mr See said.

"I was told they had just made a guess about our power consumption, because the smart meter had 'failed to give a satisfactory reading'," he said.

An EnergyAustralia representative confirmed a piece of equipment in about 60,000 smart meters had a "shorter than expected" lifespan.

About 1500 faulty meters had been replaced at the expense of the equipment's supplier since the problem was detected in August.

This type of meter was no longer being installed and newer models were expected to be more reliable.

Though the faulty meters could not be read electronically, they could still be checked manually and they still recorded power use accurately.

Customers affected by the equipment failure would not be disadvantaged, she said.

When the faulty meter was replaced, a manual reading would be taken and the account adjusted if necessary.

Mr See said his "smart" meter was changed the day after he complained.

Compoundin g the meter problem, Mr See said he had agreed to pay his bills in advance by monthly direct debits in return for a 4 per cent discount.

Because the bills were based on "guesses" of power use, which invariably favoured the retailer, the monthly withdrawals from his account kept rising until he phoned to point out that his account was hundreds of dollars in advance.

Mr See said his bill had been rectified with EnergyAustralia compensating him for the overpayments.

The EnergyAustralia representative said Mr See had been on an old-style contract until recently, so the "smart" meter failure was not entirely to blame for his high power bill.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
What about refunding the excess paid or is that to difficult for them as well. The meter readers won't read my meter as I had a mini fox terrier in my yard and marked it down as a visious dog. I was hit for estimates and my electricity was outragious.
Posted by Paccy, 15/12/2008 9:01:01 AM
I also have a smart metre installed at my new home. Historically I have used about 12 kilowatts of power daily. When renovating our new home we installed a solar hot water system and a photovotalic solar system. Naturally we expected our power usage to be negligible but in fact it has tripled to 37 kilowatts a day. I have had contact with energy Australia to be told that the metres were the best technology and that they had had no problems with them at all. I have requested the metre to be tested which was done and no problem was found. Energy Australia has acknowledged to have have the power consumption we have I would need to be running air conditioning or a pool pump 24 / 7 but they have now said it is my problem
Posted by Michelle Peden, 15/12/2008 9:36:26 AM
These are actually "dumb meters". Customers cannot see their usage over the time bands or instanteanously; are not notified if they are exceeding average use and therefor paying more than necessary and they are so smart that they still show the time before day light saving commenced. A smart meter would be able to tell the provider such things as outages in the area, feedback in real time of heavy usage, turn off customers supply in emergencies and be read remotely; just to mention a few things that already happen in other parts of the world where 'smart meters' are in use.
Posted by normara, 15/12/2008 12:59:44 PM
my home is approx 4 yrs old, in Sept 07 we were notified by Energy Aust the metres would be changed to smart metres, we have had two replaced/repaired since. my accounts are up and down, we still average about $42.00 per week usage. with my last accout i telephoned Energy Aust, they are unable to explain the usage, need our electrician to workwith us on it. also Energy Aust advised one of the metres was removed on 3.9.08, no reason given or how it will effect us. my account does not indicate we are better off. we have tried to maximise the benefits of the peak, shoulder and off peak they recommend
Posted by nk, 15/12/2008 6:25:31 PM
What kind of meters have been installe din your premises? Who's the manufacturer?
Posted by Andrei, 15/12/2008 9:06:37 PM
Anyone who has a problem with these should lodge a complaint with the Ombudsman for Energy and water - these problems need sorting out. The Ombudsman is free and can help solve the problems and the company can't give you guys the run around. They helped me. their website is www.ewon.com.au
Posted by Assissy, 23/12/2008 8:01:27 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
 SHOCKED: Laurie See said his power bills went up 30 per cent after a smart meter was installed at his home.
SHOCKED: Laurie See said his power bills went up 30 per cent after a smart meter was installed at his home.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
15 December, 2008

Most popular articles


 
Balance Health Club-Wests Tower
 
Landcom Sanctuary


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...