News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Upper Hunter negative about mining 

Upper Hunter negative about mining

15 Apr, 2011 04:00 AM
THE Upper Hunter community has a generally negative perception of the coalmining industry, despite recognising it as an economic lifeline for the region.

The stark assessment is a key finding from a NSW Minerals Council stakeholder survey that will form the basis of the Upper Hunter Mining Dialogue community consultation process.

Ninety-three stakeholder groups participated in the survey, conducted by the Australian Centre for Corporate Social Responsibility.

Participants were asked several broad questions including what changes they have seen as a result of coalmining, the benefits they have experienced, their concerns and what changes they feel need to be made to the industry.

Dust and air quality, water use and effects, public health and agricultural land impacts were the most common environment, health and safety issues raised.

An analysis of the findings concludes long-term commitment is required from the mining industry to improve its relationship with the community and to address the cumulative effects of its activities.

‘‘While it is clear that significant differences of opinion exist on what the issues are and how they should be addressed, co-operation among the mining industry and with the community will be critical moving forward,’’ the report says.

NSW Minerals Council chief executive Nikki Williams acknowledged the survey findings would challenge the industry.

‘‘While individual companies are managing environmental impacts and working with their local communities, the feedback from this survey shows that we have much more to do,’’ Dr Williams said.

‘‘These results show that there are clearly areas of difference, but we hope the Upper Hunter Mining Dialogue will be an avenue for constructive discussion between all of the stakeholders with an interest in the general well-being of the community.’’

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This is a bit late.

Mining has converted the Upper Hunter from a lifestyle in a beautiful location to a hole in the ground dirty dusty worksite.

Pitty

Now the mine want to turn Newcastle into one big dirty dusty coal loader.

Posted by bigfeller, 15/04/2011 7:22:48 AM, on The Herald
‘‘These results show that there are clearly areas of difference, but we hope the Upper Hunter Mining Dialogue will be an avenue for constructive discussion between all of the stakeholders with an interest in the general well-being of the community.’’ Awww the Minerals Council cares.

Sorry but hope is not a plan Nikki & i dont have any faith in your profiling survey nor its petty outcomes, particularly when you opportunistically are already spruiking untruths about mining

‘‘While individual companies are managing environmental impacts and working with their local communities,.." MANAGING THEIR ENVIROnMENTAL IMPACTS?! are you seriously that deluded by your own propoganda?

Posted by canary out of the coal mine, 15/04/2011 8:13:22 AM, on The Herald
*propaganda!
Posted by canary out of the coal mine, 15/04/2011 10:37:55 AM, on The Herald
It's time the people of the Hunter were offered an alternative future to what is on the table, not just a massaged version of more of the same. Land is being destroyed, waterways polluted, aquifers depleted, respiratory tracts congested, ears blasted, now climate is changing, all in pursuit Of very short term profits for a few. We're not even putting aside money for a future beyond coal, and when the govt tried to, the mining industry spent $20m on a PR campaign to defeat it. It's time to realize the madness and plan the phase out of this now out of date industry. It's time for the future, the past should stay in the past.
Posted by Let's reduce, not manage, 15/04/2011 10:38:58 AM, on The Herald
There are some towns in the Upper Hunter that would virtually cease to exist if not for mining. There are hundreds, if not thousands of people who are kept in employment, and millions upon millions of dollars injected into the community and into the environment every year by this industry.

If you take the mining away, these communities will be the first to complain when the benefits stop.

So the solution... Give up on mining, sack them all & give the community something else to whinge about? or just accept the benefits of the industry & deal with it? Lets all be honest, the mining industry (coal & other minerals) has kept this country out of recession during a GFC & will continue to do so

Posted by Benefits, 15/04/2011 11:01:08 AM, on The Herald
@Benefits. Its a finite resource, do you ever consider the legacy left for your kids? Id like a future in genuine sustainable industry & jobs , complete with a intrinsic & valued ecosystem, including farmers & land owner rights along with clean air ,water & a bill of good health. Am i to understand you consider all of these should be traded off for a few pieces of dirty silver, which ultimately only ever really benefits a short term few? No jobs on a dead planet , Mate.
Posted by Coal Miners Daughter, 15/04/2011 12:06:17 PM, on The Herald
It's really time for Hunter residents to say enough is enough - we don't want any new coal mines or any new gas operations for that matter. agriculture, tourism and renewable energy projects are a much more sustainable way of developing our economy. The impacts on health, on waterways, on agricultural land and the contribution to climate change are just not justifiable any more.
Posted by Coal is history, 15/04/2011 1:16:28 PM, on The Herald
@Benefits, Please name a couple of towns that Mining created in the upper hunter. It's a lot easier to name a few that have been wiped off the map or are in the process of being wiped of the map.

These same towns that you are worried about WILL have to face a time when there are no mines nearby because they will all eventually be mined out. The land & water that supported the farming industries that existred before Mining will not now support farming's return to this pot-holed moonscape of expired mines, so I expect these towns will die as mining has short life not forever like Farming . To support the supersized Coal loader, Super Sized Rail network and the Super expanded Mining Industry itself it will require the sacrifice of a Hunter Valley sized area of NEW MINES every 50yrs or so that replaces the current Moonscape. This is no problem for those "local supporters" of the industry that will just return the other state or country they hail from leaving local Hunter people with a big mined out polluted, unfarmable mess.

Which lucky area is going to be the next Hunter Moonscape? Gloucester? Mudgee? then Gunnedah? 50yrs of Coal cash then no Coal, no Farms, certain death!!

Posted by SPARKS, 15/04/2011 2:01:03 PM, on The Herald
We do have a negative perception of coal mines surrounding us, after years of disappointments. Money that has been generated in the Hunter has not been returned to the people of the Hunter. Mining industry used our human resources, our land in return of basic living conditions, polluted air and water, large working class with low skills and low education. We now have a population, scared of mining companies leaving the region, leaving them unemployed. It's pity that the governments have not diversified the economic life, have made our lives and our children's future totally dependent on the mining companies.


Posted by FG, 15/04/2011 2:44:43 PM, on The Herald
Benefits, you would have to be a Coal Miner to talk such rubbish. There has already been towns that have disapeared and more to go yet and as far as employment is concirned most of the workers in mines do not come from the local area they travel from other area's, not many locals get jobs in mines and its not because they are not qualified its because they dont belong to the union and union members come first. And as others have already said Mining is a short term industry and it completely wrecks the land that it has mined and the general area around the mine.
Posted by John the Mayor, 16/04/2011 5:29:48 AM, on The Herald
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles


 
Landcom Sanctuary 190512
 
 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...