News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Wine, gas, don't mix 

Wine, gas, don't mix

03 May, 2011 04:00 AM
HUNTER winemaking legends and leaders have called for the vineyard region to be ‘‘excised’’ from a coal seam gas exploration licence.

In a submission to a proposed NSW coal and gas strategy, the Hunter Valley Wine Industry Association argued Broke Fordwich and Pokolbin should be removed from AGL’s exploration licence and any future licences.

The submission has the endorsement of industry figures including Bruce Tyrrell, Brian and Fay McGuigan, the late David Clarke, Max and John Drayton, and Andrew Margan.

The former Labor government began the consultation process, releasing a discussion paper during its dying days.

The association said AGL’s licence was due to be renewed in 2012, meaning the change could be made in recognition of the significant economic contribution of the vineyards.

In its submission, the NSW Minerals Council emphasised that coalmining and coal seam gas were ‘‘fundamentally different’’ industries in terms of processes and regulations.

The council supported land use plans but argued against exclusion zones that could ‘‘quarantine’’ coal resources before a cost benefit analysis was done.

The Coalition pledged before the election to produce land-use plans, to introduce tougher project assessments and monitoring, and to protect agricultural land and water resources. A ‘‘transition’’ period was promised to begin a month after it took office.

Planning Minister Brad Hazzard has recently been ill. A spokeswoman for Resources Minister Chris Hartcher said the government was in the process of applying its policy.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
no way.... dig it all up. more short term profit in gas than grapes. whingers.
Posted by judgedredd, 3/05/2011 6:39:49 AM, on The Herald
I think i would rather be able to turn on my TV and heater than huddle around a bottle of cab sav on a winters night.
Posted by horse, 3/05/2011 7:04:12 AM, on The Herald
Extracting coal seam gas uses chemicals that poison artesian water. Benzene & toluene are among the known carcinogens used in 'fraccing'.

Qld Minister for Energy recently banned coal seam exploration fearing unwanted health outcomes for residents near exploration operations.

Solar hot water & electricity are better alternatives to the 19th century petroleum technologies.

Posted by Future Thinker, 3/05/2011 7:32:05 AM, on The Herald
I don't see why they should be any different to any other Agriculture. All farmers and graziers should be excised. Not just grape farmers.

All agriculture should be protected.

They all have possible generations of sweat and tears, and weather tolerance, to attain the same results.

Perhaps the grape growers should back all the agricultural people. They should all stand together - not expect special attention.

Posted by Guess who-Lake Macquarie, 3/05/2011 7:42:02 AM, on The Herald
And has been shown in the USA, food and gas don't mix. People are not buying food from methane gas fields. Also we have Methane Gas cowboys in the rush to bring it to the surface, dumping hundreds of thousands of litres of salty water on pasture killing it. Fortunately the Government required AGL Energy to remediate, as best they could, the dead soil, but AGL wasn't penalised for this act of environmental vandalism. Keep them out of food and winegrowing areas before they destroy it forever.
Posted by U. Downs, 3/05/2011 8:46:45 AM, on The Herald
Dear Horse,

You are forgetting that most of that coal and methane gas we are mining is not for our own use. It is to be sold cheap for export. It will be all burnt in China and India and come back to haunt us in the form of droughts, fires, floods and cyclones. Please, take time and study the science: http://www.skepticalscience.com/

Sincerely yours,

Not-horse

Posted by Not-horse, 3/05/2011 9:40:21 AM, on The Herald
Again we start to dig up Australia and destroy our nation to cater to the needs of Asia. In QLD already Origin Energy and its partner, Conoco Phillips, signed Australia’s biggest single LNG agreement with China’s Sinopec and this will involve the progressive development of coal seam gas fields. The deal through their joint venture company is worth an estimated $90 billion. It's only a matter of time before same happens here. The Hunter Valley in 30 years will be a cesspool. The extraction process draws up large volumes of underground water and apart from the salinity problem, the sheer volume of produced water extracted, and the capacity to dispose of this produced water, are a CSG project’s primary environmental concerns. Communities living and farming near the Australian coal basins need to start paying attention. Toxic spills could occur; drinking and irrigation water could be contaminated; productive farmland could be destroyed. Drilling hundreds of small wells and pumping out mega volumes of salty water might be OK in remote areas, but not in the designated agricultural and tourist regions like the Hunter Valley in NSW.
Posted by Here We Go Again, 3/05/2011 10:25:38 AM, on The Herald
Anyone who thinks coal seam gas is a good idea needs to watch a documentary called "Gasland". Once the water table is contaminated there is no going back..
Posted by No Fracking, 3/05/2011 12:51:29 PM, on The Herald
Were set to follow the same trend as QLd. they have thousands of Gas wells. They also suffer where there is GAS infrastructure Rural Farm land values have been cut by 20%. No one is interested in your life's investment only the Gas Co. that has forced wells, Roads & Pipelines onto your "PRIVATE" farmland. When the Gas is Fracced & free, it migrates where ever it likes so many vital farming water wells & bores are now just bubbling gas vents with a free dose of the Fracc Chemicals to go with it. They also pump out the water from the aquifers to reduce the pressure and free up the flow of the gas. They are full of facts, figures & promises but the bottom line is they will poison the underground water, run dirt road networks all over famland and set up hundreds of 1 acre well sites that need constant dewatering over private property & as a result produce gas for export profit. The costs are born by the communities they trample with greatly devalued land that is unsellable. Of course the Minerals Council is against restrictions they are the peak Pro Coal - Gas advocate. They are also only OK with land use plans so long as they don't restrict profits or their current activities.
Posted by SPARKS, 3/05/2011 1:26:07 PM, on The Herald
Gasland should be compulsory viewing for every adult. They can then make up their own mind.

I watched the program the other night on SBS.

I must admit, I didn't want to, but felt compelled to know more about this issue.

The program made me realise how little control the average person has over their lives and their environment, or the longlasting impact that is being sanctioned by governments.

The water supply of over 6 million people in numerous states of america is threatened, therefore their drinking water and food supplies.

How can we blindly copy the devastating outcomes that are continuing to happen overseas to many, many small communities?

Once it starts its like an avalanche, get out of the way or go under.

Posted by ollie, 3/05/2011 3:11:21 PM, on The Herald
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
MEASURING:  Monitoring equipment installed in Beyond Broke Vineyard as part of a study on the effects of coalmining at the vineyard. - Picture by Peter Stoop
MEASURING: Monitoring equipment installed in Beyond Broke Vineyard as part of a study on the effects of coalmining at the vineyard. - Picture by Peter Stoop

Most popular articles


 
Landcom Sanctuary 190512
 
 
 
 


Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...