News 
 Local News 
 Sport 
 Rugby League 
 Newcastle Knights fined, touch judge dropped after sideline spat 

Newcastle Knights fined, touch judge dropped after sideline spat

29 Jul, 2009 05:00 AM
NRL touch judge Russell Turner's mock tears have cost him and the Knights $1000 each.

Turner has been stood down from duties this weekend, meaning he will not collect the $1000 match fee for sideline officials, and the NRL fined the Knights the same amount as a result of a verbal exchange between Turner and at least one unidentified member of the Knights' coaching staff in the final minutes of Newcastle's 44-20 loss to Manly at Gosford last Friday.

After Turner ruled a forward pass from Newcastle's Matt Hilder to Danny Wicks in the 74th minute, it is understood a Knights official said from the interchange bench: "You've had one decision to make all night and you've stuffed it up."

Replays on the Channel Nine television coverage and on the video screen at Bluetongue Stadium then showed Turner, who ran the line in the second State of Origin game in Sydney last month, mimicking wiping tears from his eyes.

NRL chief operating officer Graham Annesley said the war of words continued after full-time as players and officials proceeded up the tunnel to the dressing-rooms.

Annesley said he investigated the incident and took action because the Knights lodged a complaint against Turner and not as a result of it being highlighted by television cameras.

"Who said what was really irrelevant. The fact that there was an exchange between them meant that, initially the Knights were in the wrong for making comments to the touch judge while he was carrying out his duty," Annesley said.

"But the fact that he responded and didn't just let them go through to the keeper then report the incident later meant that he was equally at fault and, consequently, that's why we took action against both the club and the touch judge."

Annesley indicated Turner's involvement saved the Knights from a stiffer penalty.

"The touch judge by his actions further exacerbated the problem, and that's why we haven't gone as heavily on the Knights as we might have otherwise," he said.

"He's stood down for a week and he would normally receive a match fee of $1000, so he's got a $1000 penalty the same as the Knights."

Annesley said the NRL would not pursue the staff member individually. It was concerned only with fining the Knights as a club.

"How they treat it from there is a matter for them."

Knights chief executive Steve Burraston said it was possible more than one person made the comments.

"We'll cop it sweet. There was a clear breach of the rules by our coaching staff member from the bench," Burraston said.

"I know it's not a player. It was one of our coaching staff, but it may well have been more than one.

"I understand it was an emotional comment made in the heat of the moment and, whilst I don't think it's a major issue, certainly it was a clear breach of the NRL operations policy."

Referring to the actual pass in banter with fellow Channel Nine commentator Ray Warren, Fairfax columnist Phil Gould said of the pass: "That ball didn't go forward. He's got his eyes painted on, that linesman. How do you call that forward, Rabbits?"

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
just goes to shows the Knghts are the NRL'S poorest losers .
Posted by amused, 29/07/2009 7:07:30 AM
Great the knights complain about an NRL official that they have to something about so what do they do. They also fine the Knights the same amount as the official. They have already put two referees on the field as the game is to fast for them maybe they need two linesmen on each side of the field. I know how about a camera on there head similar to the night vision goggles used in helicopters. This way we will see what the linesman sees now this would make interesting viewing.
Posted by BJ, 29/07/2009 7:34:25 AM
$1,000 a game for a linesman????? They would be the lowest paid official in the NRL. So how much money is all the other officials & hangers-on taking away from the clubs & players that provide the game. Every weekend the linesmen & referees would be earning more than half the players on the field. How is this "RIGHT"?.
Posted by Wally, 29/07/2009 10:02:20 AM
they were wrong anyway, it wasn't the only decision he had to make, also missed an obvious high shot and a second tackle into touch, both right in front of him.
Posted by dm, 29/07/2009 10:42:46 AM
For someone who works for 90 minutes a week, $1000 is very generous. I'm no major critic of the refs, as I realise from first hand experience how hard it is, but that sort of pay packet is excellent. Even looking at it on a per-day basis, it's incredibly-generous. That the refs and touchies made so many errors in this game was enough without him carrying on
Posted by Doc, 29/07/2009 11:14:14 AM
Good money, for running up and down a sideline without really having to make any real calls as they have the video ref to back them up. I don't mind if the touchy has a go back after coping a spray, $1000 fine for something that was fairly minimal, is a joke. You only get $300 fine for speeding in a car and potentially endangering someone's life, get some perspective NRL!!!!
Posted by Surf's up!, 29/07/2009 5:27:13 PM
Well he certainly wasn't crying real tears. I've watched this touchie for ages & let me tell you his eyes are only painted on!
Posted by Hans Murdok, 29/07/2009 7:41:41 PM
^^ I agree he made a foul up on Mondays nights game as well, We'd be better off giving the flag to Mr MaGoo !!
Posted by Mr Happy, 30/07/2009 11:22:24 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
 TOUCHY SUBJECT: Russell Turner reacts to the Knights bench, and the pass from Matt Hilder to Danny Wicks that he ruled forward. - Pictures Channel 9 and Fox Sports
TOUCHY SUBJECT: Russell Turner reacts to the Knights bench, and the pass from Matt Hilder to Danny Wicks that he ruled forward. - Pictures Channel 9 and Fox Sports

Most popular articles

Rovert
 
Travelworld_See the World
 
Scholarships
 
 
Klosters Golf GTI
 
School Newspaper Competition
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...