News 
 Opinion 
 Editorial 
 General 
 Coal opens a dialogue 

Coal opens a dialogue

15 Apr, 2011 04:00 AM
THE NSW Minerals Council deserves credit for facing up to coalmining's reputational problem in the Hunter Valley.

A report commissioned by the council from the Australian Centre for Corporate and Social Responsibility has found the community has a generally negative view of the industry and that the cumulative effects of the explosive growth in open-cut mining haven't been well addressed.

Many would say that this is old news, but to be fair, many of the issues addressed in the latest report haven't been closely studied before.

For example, the study recognises the negative health effects on people whose properties are affected by mining proposals but who aren't able to sell without suffering major loss because of potentially long-term uncertainty about the eventual impact of the planned mining.

It also acknowledges that the planning and approval process for new mines has come to be perceived as opaque and not readily open to community input.

Other concerns are more predictable. Dust pollution and its potential health effects, loss of water resources and reduction of water quality and visual impacts on the landscape are among the most obvious community complaints.

Even coal's harshest critics admit the industry's economic benefits, with the proviso that not enough appears to be done to help ensure more of these benefits might outlast the coal resource itself.

Having opened a vital conversation with the Hunter communities affected by mining, the industry is now confronted with the challenge of taking meaningful action.

Responsibility for that rests not only with the industry, but also with the government agencies charged with regulating coalmining. And perhaps most importantly, it rests with the affected communities themselves.

The Minerals Council's Upper Hunter Mining Dialogue aims to make community members better informed about the issues driving the industry's growth.

If this succeeds then the next step - soliciting help and advice from the community about how to meet industry needs without unnecessary social and environmental dislocation and about where lines must sometimes be drawn - will be much easier to achieve.

Jobs in decline

WITH the winding back of economic stimulus measures put in place by the federal government to soften the effects of the global financial crisis, the Hunter's jobless rate has ticked slightly upwards.

The construction industry, in particular, is feeling the pressure. This is not a uniquely Hunter phenomenon, with similar trends observed across Australia.

Lenders don't seem keen to fund development projects and the resulting credit squeeze is hitting developers, builders and the employees who depend on them.

Households - perhaps still nervous about the health of the global financial system - are retiring debt and accumulating savings.

With the federal government softening up taxpayers with talk of a harsh budget, Hunter people will be hoping the mining and energy boom continues.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The cumulative impact of multiple coal mines was recognised by the tiny department handling coalmine EIS's more than 30 years ago. I should know. I was one of the people in that tiny department and left in disgust as the government refused to take any notice then.

I have worked in the coal industry since then and have watched those 30 year predictions unfortunately bear fruit.

The industry generally ignored the issue, hiding behind individual property EIS's knowing there was a problem developing, and also knowing the government was providing no direction.

Look how long it took to get the Hunter River salinity scheme running? Release of polluted water during times of high flood flows was recommended in the late 1970's.

Government will have to act first. It will have to provide controls and regulation to force the industry's hand. Alone industry will never "do the right thing". The last 30 years proves that.

Posted by Harold, 16/04/2011 8:04:44 AM, on The Herald
The economic benefits are exaggerated. The NSW Government has little to show with already substantial budget deficits. Only one quarter of coal production is used domestically with the rest disappearing overseas to cater to international demand. 7% (royalties) of total production (revenue less allowable deductions) does not seem a fair return on publicly owned resources. In NSW mining employs only 1% of the workforce hardly a significant proportion and Australia wide it is about 1.6%. Mining might be powering Australia's economy, but its employment needs are tiny and the wealth generated is definitely not being shared fairly. The real economic costs, particularly environmental, are not adequately considered. Mining companies undertake short tem analysis based on coal extraction and sales rates not long term sustainability. There is little to no consideration about how long term impacts are managed in the future. Impacts can be long lasting and a legacy for future generations. The environment is more than just natural capital available for the wealth creation of miners.
Posted by Economic Benefits?, 18/04/2011 9:36:48 AM, on The Herald
We lost out when the State owned mines were sold off, they couldn't manage them then and they can't do it now that they are all owned by private enterprise. Massive loss for NSW, and the guys who lost their jobs.

Is there an answer to how badly the Government and other Authorities manage, I don't think so. And you could not trust private enterprise, all they are interested in is the all nighty $$

Posted by So over it, 18/04/2011 3:56:09 PM, on The Herald

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles




Newcastle Herald







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...