THE high Australian dollar and a global fall in aluminium prices are being blamed for job cuts in the aluminium industry ("Smeltdown" Herald 12/1). While aluminium produced using coal is far too carbon-intensive to retain global competitiveness in the long run, any blaming of the coming carbon price for job cuts is barking up the wrong tree. The commodities boom - particularly the expansion of coal exports - is the reason for the high Australian dollar. It is coal exports, not the future carbon price, that is reducing the competitiveness of this industry.
The aluminium industry is not alone. All trade-exposed sectors are affected, including manufacturing, education and tourism. There were 1000 redundancies when BlueScope Steel shut down operations in Wollongong last year. Universities are undergoing massive restructuring, collectively cutting thousands of jobs and slashing degree programs and whole faculties - also blamed on the high Australian dollar. "Greenies" are not to blame for the high Australian dollar - mining is.
Annika Dean, Hamilton East