MOST club captains believe action is needed to improve the standard of Newcastle district cricket, but opinion is divided on how to achieve that.
The Newcastle District Cricket Association is expected to reveal more details of its proposed eight-team premier league to the 12 clubs in the next two days, after an initial meeting with the presidents on February 4.
While support for the radical change to the competition appears weak among presidents and other powerbrokers, the captains are more open to the possibility.
Merewether have dominated the competition in the past year, winning two-day, 50-over, Twenty20 and SCG Country Cup titles, and vice-captain Troy Goodwin said the premier league was needed.
"It needs to go to eight teams for the good of Newcastle," Goodwin said.
"If we want to compete in the Twenty20 comp in Sydney next year, cricket in Newcastle has got to strengthen."
Stockton-Raymond Terrace skipper Nick Foster and University counterpart Josh Emerton are also supporters.
"They really do need to look at the premier league or cutting a couple of teams back, which will in turn make those players go to other first-grade clubs and make them stronger, which is obviously good for the entire comp," Emerton said.
Almost three years ago, the NDCA proposed cutting the competition to 10 sides before five of the six clubs threatened to form a voting bloc to defeat the plan.
Veteran Charlestown skipper Steve Mace and first-season Wallsend captain Brett Jackson, whose clubs are struggling, both believe standards will rise only through mergers or cutting sides.
Neither supports a premier league.
"I think the competition has to bite the bullet and actually reduce the number of clubs, whether it be us merge with someone, or someone else," Jackson said.
"I just think there's definitely too many clubs and obviously not enough quality players in the top grade.
"With this premier league, who's going to want to play in the second division?"
Jackson, one of the competition's leading batsmen, said he would likely leave Wallsend if they were relegated, as he aspired to play the best standard of cricket possible.
Mark Littlewood (Belmont), Ben Woolmer (Wests) and Steve Christie (Waratah-Mayfield) are open to change to improve the competition but are unsure about the premier league until more details are released.
Hamwicks captain Kirk Mullard and Toronto skipper Joe Price believe the competition does not need big changes.
"You can't have some clubs with the best players in the comp playing in the lower leagues, like for instance the rep captain [Littlewood]," Mullard said.
Hamwicks have won the past three minor premierships and lead the competition.
"It's just evolution; it goes around in a roundabout," Mullard said.
Mullard said that when he joined in the mid-90s Hamwicks ran eighth or ninth.
"We've been very successful, but we're under no illusion that at some stage the run will come to an end."