A CONTROVERSIAL Central Coast underground coal mine proposal can be managed to minimise impacts on the region’s water supply, said Environment Minister Melissa Price after approving the Wallarah 2 mine in a decision objectors say will cost the Federal Government a vital seat.
“You can almost kiss the seat of Robertson goodbye with this one. This will backfire on the Federal Government,” said Australian Coal Alliance spokesperson Mike Campbell after Ms Price signed off on one of the final hurdles facing the mine, after more than two decades of community opposition.
Ms Price accepted Federal Department of Environment advice that the impacts on water and threatened species and communities could be monitored and managed.
Under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act assessment and approval Wallarah 2’s owner Kores, owned by the South Korean Government and Korean and Japanese mining interests, is required to prepare a trigger action response plan to identify early warning, mitigation and cease work triggers for affected watercourses, water supply and biodiversity measures.
Kores is also required to prepare a groundwater management plan and separate Central Coast water supply arrangement management plan that calculates the loss of water from Wyong River and other water sources caused by mining in the water catchment area.
The approval on Friday includes 31 conditions, in addition to 89 conditions imposed by the former NSW Planning Assessment Commission in January, 2018 after it approved the mine nearly 5 kilometres north of Wyong, despite conceding the risk of serious and irreversible damage to the Central Coast’s water supply is real.
The 89 conditions include the ability to shut down the mine if adverse impacts are beyond those anticipated and a requirement that Wallarah 2 provide 300 megalitres a year of treated water to the Central Coast catchment to compensate for any potential loss caused by mining.
Lock the Gate Alliance condemned the Federal Minister’s decision on Friday as “reckless and short-sighted”.
“This summer is showing us how precious water is and how disastrous it can be and how vulnerable we are when water runs dry,” Lock the Gate spokesperson Georgina Woods said.
“It’s reckless and unacceptable for a coal mine to undermine the water for the growing cities of the NSW Central Coast, which has suffered from water shortages in the past.
“At a time like this, our governments should not be putting precious water resources at risk, especially not for new thermal coal mines.”
Australian Coal Alliance founder Alan Hayes said the group would consider a court challenge to the Federal decision, similar to its challenge to the NSW decision heard in the Land and Environment Court. A determination on the NSW challenge is not expected until at least April. Central Coast Council, which strongly opposes the Wallarah 2 mine, contributed $200,000 to the legal challenge.
“This is a proposed mine in a water catchment, and it’s the only water catchment the Central Coast’s got,” Mr Hayes said.
“We’ve requested the documents the Federal Minister has relied on to make this decision, and the government’s got 28 days to provide them. We will look at them and decide about a challenge but what I can say is that despite this latest approval, this has still got a long way to go.”
The NSW Planning Assessment Commission approved the underground mine to produce up to five million tonnes of coal for 25 years. The coal would be exported to Korea and used in “local domestic power stations”, it said.
It noted that demand for coal for 25 years and the acceptability of greenhouse gas emissions associated with the end use of coal remained “significant uncertainties for the project”.
The commission acknowledged subsidence of up to 2.6 metres beneath a state forest area; increased flooding impacts for more than 170 property owners that could require lifting or relocating homes and increased flooding impacts affecting 15 bridges and roads.
It also acknowledged that “economic costs and benefits of the project are finely balanced, with inevitable uncertainties about demand for thermal coal 20 years in to the future”, after Kores’ economic benefit estimate of $1.56 billion to the state was reduced to $32 million in a report commissioned by the Department of Planning.
Liberal MP for Robertson Lucy Wicks holds the seat with a margin of 3.1 per cent. Robertson has been targeted by Labor as a winnable seat at the Federal election.
Deeper reading: NSW election 2019
- Primary Industries Minister Niall Blair says only 'very brave person' would remove shark nets despite drum-line trial (January 21, 2019)
- Newcastle Art Gallery expansion project grows beyond $40m as Tim Crakanthorp revives Labor funding commitment (January 21, 2019)
- Liberals' Scot MacDonald out of running for Newcastle and Maitland (January 21, 2019)
- Long road ahead for Nelson Bay despite Gladys Berejiklian funding commitment (January 20, 2019)
- Labor lines up Cessnock deputy mayor Melanie Dagg to replace Martin Rush as Upper Hunter candidate (January 19, 2019)
- Greens announce candidates for Newcastle and Wallsend (January 17, 2019)
- Premier Gladys Berejiklian says extra $100m Hunter Water dividend will flow into state's consolidated revenue (January 15, 2019)
- Premier Gladys Berejiklian announces another $205 million for Nelson Bay Road upgrade (Janaury 15, 2019)
- Liberal Party spends $700m in Newcastle but no candidates in sight (January 15, 2019)